Start or Sit? Week 1!

[SJ76]

You act like it isn’t even debateable.

And that is crazy.

Rodgers is at the end of his career. Mahomes is just getting started. Already same number of Super Bowl wins.

And how many guys have played with both?

Watkins and who? Watkins currently plays with Rodgers so of course he is going to go with ARod.

It’s close just go look at what the players voted on the top 100. Mahomes skills are elite but Rodgers is still really good and his IQ is off the chart. Not to mention Mahomes has had a top 10 overall player in Kelce. Both have had elite WRs but this isn’t fantasy we are talking


It’s ok I love you stat boys.

 

[Iggloo]

Let's just say that starting Cam Akers and Allen Robinson last night was not optimal. Akers is likely never to see the lineup again this season after what I witnessed last night. He looks absolutely cooked. No burst, no power, no heart as a runner.

 

[molsaniceman]

It’s close just go look at what the players voted on the top 100. Mahomes skills are elite but Rodgers is still really good and his IQ is off the chart. Not to mention Mahomes has had a top 10 overall player in Kelce. Both have had elite WRs but this isn’t fantasy we are talking


It’s ok I love you stat boys.

name the player in the top 100 who has only played 4 seasons Ill wait

 

[SJ76]

name the player in the top 100 who has only played 4 seasons Ill wait

No one is talking upside or youth. We are talking right now. These are actual NFL players voting and saying this.


It’s not hard people.

 

[Shanemansj13]

I do love you stat geeks here tho. Fantasy yeah Mahomes over Rodgers or at least that was the case when Hill was in KC. We will see this year.


Another Hint:

Go check out the top 100 players ranked and voted by actual NFL players.


It’s all on the internet folks

Sorry to tell you but right now, it is very debatable and a lot will take Mahomes now and obviously for the future.

 

[Shanemansj13]

No one is talking upside or youth. We are talking right now. These are actual NFL players voting and saying this.


It’s not hard people.

Yep we are too. Follow along. Not many are taking Rodgers over Mahomes right now, sorry to tell you.

Like I have said time and time again NFL players can be very slighted. Tyreek Hill said Tua throws a better ball than Patty LOL.

You go off every NFL players' opinions though.

 

[molsaniceman]

No one is talking upside or youth. We are talking right now. These are actual NFL players voting and saying this.


It’s not hard people.

hes 3rd on this list with both having same problem they lost their binky

Top 100 NFL Players of 2022: Aaron Donald is No. 1 as Rams have three of top 10; Aaron Rodgers No. 2

Pete Prisco keeps Tom Brady near the top even at nearly 45, while the Chargers have the most in top 100

www.cbssports.com

 

[SJ76]

Yep we are too. Follow along. Not many are taking Rodgers over Mahomes right now, sorry to tell you.

Like I have said time and time again NFL players can be very slighted. Tyreek Hill said Tua throws a better ball than Patty LOL.

You go off every NFL players' opinions though.

Lol at NFL players are “slighted”. Basically give no value to those players opinions on the game. But you internet stat boys know more than the actual players.


Lmao this is gold

 

[SJ76]

View attachment 307751
hes 3rd on this list with both having same problem they lost their binky

Top 100 NFL Players of 2022: Aaron Donald is No. 1 as Rams have three of top 10; Aaron Rodgers No. 2

Pete Prisco keeps Tom Brady near the top even at nearly 45, while the Chargers have the most in top 100

www.cbssports.com

Yeah we are splitting hairs here. Lol

Whole point was more Sammy Watkins is in a good place in GB. Who knows what he actually does but the guy was 3rd or 4th option at KC and Balt. Has loads of talent but internet geeks know more than he does apparently.


All good tho

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Yeah we are splitting hairs here. Lol

Whole point was more Sammy Watkins is in a good place in GB. Who knows what he actually does but the guy was 3rd or 4th option at KC and Balt. Has loads of talent but internet geeks know more than he does apparently.


All good tho

i wouldnt say good place... but definitely better... i dont think anyone would be shocked if Watkins becomes a valuable WR for the packers, but also nobody would be surprised if he gets released by week 3...

 

[SJ76]

i wouldnt say good place... but definitely better... i dont think anyone would be shocked if Watkins becomes a valuable WR for the packers, but also nobody would be surprised if he gets released by week 3...

Too much talent to be released but I hear you.

As far as a QB that be a coach on the field…. As far as competition of other WRs. Their philosophy as an offense. He’s in the best spot possible for him so it’s time shine or not

 

[molsaniceman]

i wouldnt say good place... but definitely better... i dont think anyone would be shocked if Watkins becomes a valuable WR for the packers, but also nobody would be surprised if he gets released by week 3...

well lazard is out so it just got better

 

[Shanemansj13]

Too much talent to be released but I hear you.

As far as a QB that be a coach on the field…. As far as competition of other WRs. Their philosophy as an offense. He’s in the best spot possible for him so it’s time shine or not

That guy with too much talent hasn't produced a 100 yard game since early 2019. If he can stay healthy he is a good option, I wouldn't expect much from him bc he is a guy that can easily let you down. His catch rate is just too low

 

[SJ76]

That guy with too much talent hasn't produced a 100 yard game since early 2019. If he can stay healthy he is a good option, I wouldn't expect much from him bc he is a guy that can easily let you down. His catch rate is just too low

All true but at pick 191 and no proven WRs in GB. Why not

 

[SJ76]

well lazard is out so it just got better

 

[Shanemansj13]

All true but at pick 191 and no proven WRs in GB. Why not

Ohh sure. A late pick but starting him week one is risky unless you are in a very deep league/ 16 teamer. Just a risky player that’s all

 

[tlance]

It’s close just go look at what the players voted on the top 100. Mahomes skills are elite but Rodgers is still really good and his IQ is off the chart. Not to mention Mahomes has had a top 10 overall player in Kelce. Both have had elite WRs but this isn’t fantasy we are talking


It’s ok I love you stat boys.

Rodgers has a much better run game which, IMO at least cancels out the Kelce advantage. Teams know the only way KC can beat you is through the air and they still do. GB is much more balanced.

You want to pick Rodgers, then fine. There is a case to be made.

But your first comment made it sound like it isn’t even close.

And it most definitely is.

 

[SJ76]

Rodgers has a much better run game which, IMO at least cancels out the Kelce advantage. Teams know the only way KC can beat you is through the air and they still do. GB is much more balanced.

You want to pick Rodgers, then fine. There is a case to be made.

But your first comment made it sound like it isn’t even close.

And it most definitely is.

Nope my comment was in reference to Sammy W being in the best situation he’s ever been in. Yes he says ARod is on a different level. And he should be he’s more experienced


I never said Arod is light years ahead of Mahomes.

 

[SJ76]

Ohh sure. A late pick but starting him week one is risky unless you are in a very deep league/ 16 teamer. Just a risky player that’s all

Of course. I’ve got AJ Dillon as my flex but it’s tempting. Kinda lol

I’ll wait and see what he does first 2 weeks

 

[tlance]

You can’t possibly really think Mahomes is better than ARod.

Not to mention Watkins was WR 3 or 4 on KC.

This is the comment I quoted.

Yes.

This comment implies you don’t think it is close since someone “couldn’t possibly think that Mahomes is better”.

So if you are walking that back, then cool. That is what I had issue with. Not that you think Rodgers is better.

And I 100% guarantee that if Watkins played in GB the last 2 seasons and was now in KC, he would be saying Mahomes is better. He is politicking.

Now, ask him after he retires and then you might get a legit answer.