Considering that there's an open field of metrics that can be used to prove or disprove one side or the other of this question, I'll use Super-Bowl MVPs as my metric. Let's begin by agreeing that QB's get far too much credit and not enough of the blame for wins and losses respectively, this skews how the position is valued.I shall ask again if someone can actually point me toward this mythical QB who won the Super Bowl without any great players around him.