Aaron Rodgers is the GOAT

[Manster7588]

The facepalm was mainly for the Troy Aikman part. Dude was the most overrated QB in history, as already pointed out above.

Most overrated in HISTORY?

 

[tabascojet]

rodgers is more goatse than goat......not that there is anything wrong with that

 

[The Derski]

Most overrated in HISTORY?

In the sense that he always gets lumped in with all time greats, yeah. Kind of like how Ginobili and Parker will be first ballot HOFers in the NBA with largely above average stats but a ton of rings.

 

[Nosferatu]

Brees, Brady, and Manning are all more GOAT worthy than Rodgers

 

[Nosferatu]

The facepalm was mainly for the Troy Aikman part. Dude was the most overrated QB in history, as already pointed out above.

Nonsense, Aikman was one of the most accurate QB's of all time, when you think of the Dallas big three he was the best of them...

 

[The Derski]

Nonsense, Aikman was one of the most accurate QB's of all time, when you think of the Dallas big three he was the best of them...

He’s 36th all time in completion %. Not bad but not amazing. Granted that stat is dominated by players in the “current era”.

 

[Nosferatu]

He’s 36th all time in completion %. Not bad but not amazing. Granted that stat is dominated by players in the “current era”.

lolzzz Favre is 27th, that's not the deciding factor in greatness. He would have much better TD numbers if they didn't hand the ball to Emmitt four times everytime they got inside the 10.

I hate the Cowboys have all my life but Aikman is not overrated if anything he's underrated.

 

[Manster7588]

In the sense that he always gets lumped in with all time greats, yeah. Kind of like how Ginobili and Parker will be first ballot HOFers in the NBA with largely above average stats but a ton of rings.

So is he the Most Overrated or just the most overrated along with a select few?

I do understand GB fans not liking Aikman the way he kicked your asses all over the place.

 

[broncosmitty]

Not sure why this guy is employed. He is an idiot, he sounds like an idiot too.

The dude keeps getting suspended for comments or falsely reporting everywhere he works, he is a joke.

I've hated the guy for decades.


Years and years before I ever knew what his voice sounded like.

 

[broncosmitty]

But ARodg is the GOAT imo.

Peyton 2nd.

Not even a debate for me.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

But ARodg is the GOAT imo.

Peyton 2nd.

Not even a debate for me.

Let me guess Elway 3rd and Tebow 4th?

 

[PickleRick]

How do i get rid of the reply option when i accidentally hit respond? Yeah, im noob as hell.

 

[Manster7588]

How do i get rid of the reply option when i accidentally hit respond? Yeah, im noob as hell.

Delete everything in the post and then hit the save or delete button.

 

[Across The Field]

LOL...this post figures....biggest problem with you is you think your opinions are gospel

His first SB win tells a different story, as does the NFC championship game they lost to the niners when they got down 21-0. Aikman was at his best when the lights were the brightest. Thankfully most agree with me, thus he's in the HOF

still looking for the great QB with little to know talent around him

Like your fellow Dallas fans, the biggest problem is you have an over-inflated opinion about your own players. Aikman on almost any other team is an above-average starter at best.

 

[PickleRick]

Delete everything in the post and then hit the save or delete button.

Thx bro.

 

[GNG]

not really....I always thought that to be Dak

 

[GNG]

Like your fellow Dallas fans, the biggest problem is you have an over-inflated opinion about your own players. Aikman on almost any other team is an above-average starter at best.

You keep blabbering about things you know so little about.

 

[GNG]

But ARodg is the GOAT imo.

Peyton 2nd.

Not even a debate for me.

 

[GNG]

 

[Nosferatu]

Like your fellow Dallas fans, the biggest problem is you have an over-inflated opinion about your own players. Aikman on almost any other team is an above-average starter at best.

I think we are all guilty of overvaluing our favorite teams players (EX... I think Randy Moss is the best WR of all time) but Aikman was the glue on that team, it's Irvin and especially Emmitt who would have been above average at best on another team.