Trade Help Needed- Shady

[oaknightshockey1]

So I, like many, have been very disappointed with McCoy so far this year. I just got two trade offers for him from the same guy.

My options are:

McCoy for Ahmad Bradshaw and Mike Wallace

or

McCoy for Ahmad Bradshaw and Andre Johnson

or

Keep McCoy.

My RBs are pretty thin at the moment, but it's not like McCoy has really been helping with that. My other RBs are Ball, Hillman, Sankey, and Helu. It's a PPR league. HELP!

 

[oaknightshockey1]

WRs I have right now are Cobb, Hopkins, T. Williams, Quick, and Malcom Floyd.

 

[SoShady]

I would keep McCoy. Neither deal is good enough. Maybe if you get a more reliable WR out of him because Johnson and Wallace doesn't get it done for me. You would really be putting a lot of faith into Bradshaw keeping it up and staying healthy. McCoy's line is getting healthy now. Kelce is a head of schedule and practicing. As well as Mathis is back at practice. Johnson should be getting up to 100% now as well.

 

[TKOSpikes]

100% agree with Shady.

 

[oaknightshockey1]

That's the way I am leaning right now, but do you think there would be any value in getting Johnson and then being able to deal Hopkins for someone? He is just so inconsistent.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I don't like trading an elite player and the best player I get back is a #2... If I am to trade McCoy, I would want a low end #1 WR and a #2 RB or something like that... If McCoy does anything like we expected from him he will nearly outperform Bradshaw and Wallace/Johnson combined...

 

[oaknightshockey1]

Told him no and he offered to throw in the 9ers d but that doesn't do much for me. I have the pats.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I would keep McCoy. Neither deal is good enough. Maybe if you get a more reliable WR out of him because Johnson and Wallace doesn't get it done for me. You would really be putting a lot of faith into Bradshaw keeping it up and staying healthy. McCoy's line is getting healthy now. Kelce is a head of schedule and practicing. As well as Mathis is back at practice. Johnson should be getting up to 100% now as well.

If I owned McCoy, I'd hold on and hope for a rebound, but truthfully there is a good chance that Bradshaw and Wallace produce more points then McCoy. I really don't think a McCoy owner could expect a better offer, at this point. Your rolling the dice either way.

 

[SteelersPride]

i agree with shady i have nothing more to add

 

[oaknightshockey1]

Another guy in my league just offered me Gio Bernard for him...tempting, but the fact that so many people are trying to get McCoy makes me want to keep him. I'm sure if I trade him he'll go off and if I keep him he'll keep being shitty

 

[SteelersPride]

Another guy in my league just offered me Gio Bernard for him...tempting, but the fact that so many people are trying to get McCoy makes me want to keep him. I'm sure if I trade him he'll go off and if I keep him he'll keep being shitty

bernard and what......thats waht i would ask him

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Another guy in my league just offered me Gio Bernard for him...tempting, but the fact that so many people are trying to get McCoy makes me want to keep him. I'm sure if I trade him he'll go off and if I keep him he'll keep being shitty

I'd go for that trade myself, but then I do love making a trade.

 

[oaknightshockey1]

bernard and what......thats waht i would ask him

Yup. We are playing each other this week so the trade is getting put on hold. If he comes back with Gio and someone else (his lineup is stacked) I'll probably take it.

 

[Sam Sportboy]

Another guy in my league just offered me Gio Bernard for him...tempting, but the fact that so many people are trying to get McCoy makes me want to keep him. I'm sure if I trade him he'll go off and if I keep him he'll keep being shitty

I agree with those who say Gio and one more.................

 

[Stomp]

I'd rather have Gio, but if you think you can get more go for it

 

[richig07]

i agree with shady i have nothing more to add

 

[Old Lion]

The idea is that he is trying to buy low on Shady. Don't fall for it. What WRs are available on your WW?

 

[broncosmitty]

i agree with shady i have nothing more to add

:rollseyes: