Trade: Harper for Scherzer

[Beengay fudgepackers]

It's a standard non keeper ten team league with 10 categories including rs, hrs, rbis, avg, sbs, Ws, Ks, Svs, era and whip. 5 outfield spots and no caps for pitchers.My outfield consists of trout, rios, Harper, G Polanco, Springer, Morse, Martinez. I also have Abreu, Gonzalez, dozier, Gordon, Frazier, a Escobar, and Ramos (I'll probably stash gattis when cliff Lee comes back from the DL.)My pitching includes Tanaka, Bumgarner, Cliff Lee, Zimmerman, Heaney, taijuan walker, Duffy, Phil Hughes, melancon, Nathan, Robertson and Rodney.I feel like my hitting is stacked. I have a trade of rios and melancon/Nathan for scherzer and archer on the table that he is considering, but I think he'll reject. I'm not sure if giving up Harper is too much for a starter of scherzer's level. I just want to load up on quality starters since the best team in the league has great pitching (Kershaw, Darvish, Price, Kimbrel, Holland, Fister, iwakuma, rosenthal, uehara, Elias, eovaldi, and Guthrie.) Opinions?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I would much rather have scherzer than harper... So if you can get him, then get him... I don't think the other team will make this trade though...

 

[Beengay fudgepackers]

He's actually offering it.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

take it and run!!! Scherzer is not having a great season, but then again Harper has been hurt all season... But even with scherzer having a subpar season he still has 9 wins and 132 Ks...


Harper is at best a an OF #3 at this point in a 10 team league


Plus it is non keeper, so who cares about the future!!!

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

take it and run!!! Scherzer is not having a great season, but then again Harper has been hurt all season... But even with scherzer having a subpar season he still has 9 wins and 132 Ks...


Harper is at best a an OF #3 at this point in a 10 team league


Plus it is non keeper, so who cares about the future!!!

Yes yes yes - Take Scherzer and drop baby Harper.

 

[tlance]

I would much rather have scherzer than harper... So if you can get him, then get him... I don't think the other team will make this trade though...

I agree. Harper is insanely overrated in fantasy terms. I think he will be a fantasy star one day, but it isn't today.

 

[TKOSpikes]

All aboard the yes bus! Your biggest worry with Mad Max is when he only gets 8 K's in a start.

 

[Beengay fudgepackers]

All aboard the yes bus! Your biggest worry with Mad Max is when he only gets 8 K's in a start.

Yeah, he can blow up you era on any given day as well. That's the same with just about anyone though. And thanks for the help everyone.

 

[Beengay fudgepackers]

the trade was accepted. THanks for all the input. I was on the other side of the fence before I listened to you guys.

 

[tlance]

the trade was accepted. THanks for all the input. I was on the other side of the fence before I listened to you guys.

Good luck!