The Umbrella Academy

[The Q]

Yep. Constantly making bad decisions & making things worse for everyone else. It would have been better had she tragically sacrificed herself to save the world (rectifying her own mistake) instead of the time-travel nonsense they could have redirected the entire focus of the show in S2.

i mean it’s based on the comics and she didn’t do that in the source material, so I get them not making that major change.

but they do a bad job building her up soupy feel bad for her.

 

[ill]

this is how I feel, except I really connect with Luther. they messed up on his powers though and it makee

five is super entertaining. Klous is in small doses

I think they do a very bad making you feel bad for vanya. Which i think they were trying to do.

I think they are going for pitiable for all of the characters as they all have their own struggles that they are dealing with on top of having these powers.

Five is the only one who has his shit somewhat together, but he is all a psychopath.

I think emo is the right way to describe them.

 

[ill]

Yep. Constantly making bad decisions & making things worse for everyone else. It would have been better had she tragically sacrificed herself to save the world (rectifying her own mistake) instead of the time-travel nonsense they could have redirected the entire focus of the show in S2.

I wonder what they do with the character now that whatshername is now whatshisname.

 

[The Q]

I think they are going for pitiable for all of the characters as they all have their own struggles that they are dealing with on top of having these powers.

Five is the only one who has his shit somewhat together, but he is all a psychopath.

I think emo is the right way to describe them.

yeah. I can’t relate to some of them.

five is just entertaining as all hell fir me.

Luther I just get. When they made the moon discovery, it was just heartbreaking

plus the chick he loves has married two different men (that Weren’t him) in two different timelines

 

[The Q]

I wonder what they do with the character now that whatshername is now whatshisname.

I’d be done.

this show isn’t nearly good enough for me to put up with that bullshit

 

[ill]

I’d be done.

this show isn’t nearly good enough for me to put up with that bullshit

whatever

won't bother me.

the show and character and weird enough that they should be able to do something with it without any issues

 

[ill]

yeah. I can’t relate to some of them.

five is just entertaining as all hell fir me.

Luther I just get. When they made the moon discovery, it was just heartbreaking

plus the chick he loves has married two different men (that Weren’t him) in two different timelines

exactly.

and Clause lost the man he loved in the war when he time traveled.

I think the individual stories are kind of more interesting than the overall story being told...at least before the end of S2

 

[The Q]

exactly.

and Clause lost the man he loved in the war when he time traveled.

I think the individual stories are kind of more interesting than the overall story being told...at least before the end of S2

completely agree with the last part. Having no context into what happened to everyone before coming back to the mansion both helps and hurts. Cause there’s no Origin and breakup story.

I think Allison’s story is that she got to be a star but I think she used her powers to get there, because she said in s2 this was the first thing she earned.

I’m sure what Diego’s story is except he’s just angry all the time and jealous of Luther’s role as the leader (problem is they de powered Luther ans made him a terrible leader, and I’m not even talking about how he handled Vanya trying to kill Allison, which at least made logical sense).

clouse’s is weird because it didn’t exist before s1 and then just came outta nowhere.

but them all ignoring the obvious rules of time travel was just brutal

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

I wonder what they do with the character now that whatshername is now whatshisname.

I’d be done.

this show isn’t nearly good enough for me to put up with that bullshit

What makes you guys think her personal choice would affect her character that’s she’s being paid to play?

Shouldn’t have any affect unless the writers make it a point to add that political/cultural message into her role. Doubt they would.

 

[The Q]

What makes you guys think her personal choice would affect her character that’s she’s being paid to play?

Shouldn’t have any affect unless the writers make it a point to add that political/cultural message into her role. Doubt they would.

not saying it would.

But if it did. The show just isn’t good enough for me to put up with such nonsense

 

[ill]

What makes you guys think her personal choice would affect her character that’s she’s being paid to play?

Shouldn’t have any affect unless the writers make it a point to add that political/cultural message into her role. Doubt they would.

well she goes by Elliot now...it might be obvious that Vanya is a dude now.

 

[ill]

completely agree with the last part. Having no context into what happened to everyone before coming back to the mansion both helps and hurts. Cause there’s no Origin and breakup story.

I think Allison’s story is that she got to be a star but I think she used her powers to get there, because she said in s2 this was the first thing she earned.

I’m sure what Diego’s story is except he’s just angry all the time and jealous of Luther’s role as the leader (problem is they de powered Luther ans made him a terrible leader, and I’m not even talking about how he handled Vanya trying to kill Allison, which at least made logical sense).

clouse’s is weird because it didn’t exist before s1 and then just came outta nowhere.

but them all ignoring the obvious rules of time travel was just brutal

"rules of time travel"

dude...it's all fiction and there are no "rules"

anything you consider a "rule" is just theory.

 

[The Q]

"rules of time travel"

dude...it's all fiction and there are no "rules"

anything you consider a "rule" is just theory.

not Changing history cause you’re bored seems pretty obvious to me

 

[ill]

not Changing history cause you’re bored seems pretty obvious to me

sorry that it upsets you.

maybe go read some Blake Crouch if you want there to be "rules"

 

[The Q]

sorry that it upsets you.

maybe go read some Blake Crouch if you want there to be "rules"

which ones?

 

[The Q]

sorry that it upsets you.

maybe go read some Blake Crouch if you want there to be "rules"

I’m just saying it seems like common sense, especially if you’d expect to go back to your normal timeline

 

[ill]

which ones?

Dark Matter was good, but I think that was more string theory.

Recursion was time travel

 

[ill]

I’m just saying it seems like common sense, especially if you’d expect to go back to your normal timeline

I mean it depends on how detailed you want to get with what their time travel is going to affect.

 

[The Q]

I mean it depends on how detailed you want to get with what their time travel is going to affect.

confronting “dad”

changing peoples destinies (like the woman and kid moving across the country)

trying to stop a famous presidential assassination

starting a brand new cult...

so many lives have been changed

what they need to explain is how he knew not to select any of them in the future when he didn’t know their real names.

 

[The Q]

What makes you guys think her personal choice would affect her character that’s she’s being paid to play?

Shouldn’t have any affect unless the writers make it a point to add that political/cultural message into her role. Doubt they would.

And yet they did

Elliot Page's "Umbrella Academy" character will come out as transgender in Season 3

Season 3 of "The Umbrella Academy" is set to premiere on June 22.

www.cbsnews.com

Interesting article to show much else they botched in the name of wokeness

8 Major Changes: The Umbrella Academy Comic Vs Show | Book Riot

Adaption always leads to changes from the source material, so here's a rundown of The Umbrella Academy: comic vs. show.

bookriot.com