POLL Realistic Playoff Scenario: Who gets the #4 Spot?

[Across The Field]

No injuries are part of the game.And you claimed the Penn State loss was a fluke. Because well blocked field goals aren't football plays or part of the game...... You've basically contradicted and continue to contradict everything you stood by last season. Which would be hypocritical by definition. I get it we all want to see our favorite teams in. But that doesn't change facts.If the season ends in this scenerio top three rankings based on resume and past practices would read
Miami
UGA
ND

Literally, not by any single measure, is this true. You not being able to understand how ND, Miami, and UGA wouldn't have near the resume that OSU had last year is your problem, not mine.

 

[963BUSC]

How would OSU be in with 3 losses? They’re a 2-loss team.

Pretty sure a 2-loss B1G champ gets in ahead of a 2-loss PAC champ this season.

The quote he posted that OSU would get in was off of a scenario where OSU had 3 losses but won the BIG. Granted its not a likely scenario but it was from the post he listed, and quoted again in the post you quoted?

And no a 2 loss BIG champ that was blown out twice should not get in ahead of any other 2 loss team. What huge OOC wins does the BIG have that makes their champ so great?

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Literally, not by any single measure, is this true. You not being able to understand how ND, Miami, and UGA wouldn't have near the resume that OSU had last year is your problem, not mine.

I would hope you don't actually believe that.I'm sure you're not contradicting your stances. On why you felt OSU belonged in the play offs last year. We can compare them in a bit. Which would be very hypocritical.......

 

[7Samurai13]

The quote he posted that OSU would get in was off of a scenario where OSU had 3 losses but won the BIG. Granted its not a likely scenario but it was from the post he listed, and quoted again in the post you quoted?

And no a 2 loss BIG champ that was blown out twice should not get in ahead of any other 2 loss team. What huge OOC wins does the BIG have that makes their champ so great?

Maryland hammered Texas

Sad but that is the best OOC win for the Big this year.

 

[Mike A. S.]

Maryland hammered Texas

Sad but that is the best OOC win for the Big this year.

That's sad for two reasons. Most importantly that a win over Texas is the best OOC win for the whole conference. But also that Maryland has the conference's best OOC win!

 

[7Samurai13]

That's sad for two reasons. Most importantly that a win over Texas is the best OOC win for the whole conference. But also that Maryland has the conference's best OOC win!

So many levels of sadness in my statement.

 

[BigAppleBadger]

The quote he posted that OSU would get in was off of a scenario where OSU had 3 losses but won the BIG. Granted its not a likely scenario but it was from the post he listed, and quoted again in the post you quoted?

And no a 2 loss BIG champ that was blown out twice should not get in ahead of any other 2 loss team. What huge OOC wins does the BIG have that makes their champ so great?

Regardless, the B1G has better national perception than the PAC, and conference championships matter. They have to matter.

 

[7Samurai13]

Regardless, the B1G has better national perception than the PAC, and conference championships matter. They have to matter.

They didn’t matter last year, why do they have to matter this season?

 

[RobBase]

13-0 Wisconsin.

 

[BigAppleBadger]

They didn’t matter last year, why do they have to matter this season?

The analogy to OSU last season would be if Alabama lost to Auburn. They’d still get in. I said that already.

 

[Voltaire26]

Still a lot of football left to play ... it's easier to call teams out of it than in ... things will get even clearer this week and the week after y'all can start arguing

 

[Wamu]

Still a lot of football left to play ... it's easier to call teams out of it than in ... things will get even clearer this week and the week after y'all can start arguing

I'll go out on a limb & say meeeechegan is out. What do you think?

 

[packerzrule]

 

[7Samurai13]

I'll go out on a limb & say meeeechegan is out. What do you think?

You know damn well that when the committee can find an excuse to include Michigan they will be in there.

 

[Voltaire26]

I'll go out on a limb & say meeeechegan is out. What do you think?

I think that's reasonable if not obvious ... if this were another thread, I'd probably say something else.

 

[Voltaire26]

You know damn well that when the committee can find an excuse to include Michigan they will be in there.

I would say some of their picks, they will be thinking about ratings, but first, we have to give them an excuse

 

[Wamu]

13-0 Wisconsin.

 

[Wamu]

You know damn well that when the committee can find an excuse to include Michigan they will be in there.

Excellent point.

 

[Wamu]

I think that's reasonable if not obvious ... if this were another thread, I'd probably say something else.

Okay which thread? I'm interested in what you have to say.

 

[Wamu]