mariota vs winston

[SteelersPride]

for fantasy

who u got this year, and going forward

 

[Stomp]

After Brady and Rodgers they're really all the same to me. I'd give Winston a very slight edge since i think he's less likely to get himself injured.

 

[Brees#1]

Mariota.

 

[Chef99]

I like 'em both. If Mariota is healthy again, I might give him an edge.

 

[TREFF]

Until Mariota has more proven, bonafied threats to utilize, I'm going Winston and it ain't even close.

Davis might be a great WR, someday, it likely won't be this year and even if he is "a success", he's not likely going to be some game changing force. And he may very well be yet another 1st round WR bust. Mathews is nice, but no world beater, Walker is becoming less of a factor and is aging. And, when Marriota runs, he's not the most durable dude in the game.

But Winston has Evans, DJAX, and Brate/Howard, and he's not a guy we worry about getting blasted by the defense on QB runs.

2-3 years into the future, if DJAX slows, Howard busts, and Davis is a "next big thing", maybe that changes, but not for now

 

[SmokingMonkey]

I know there's no world beaters on the list, but i think what Decker and Mathews brings to compliment the smash mouth Murray Henry combo will play nicely this yr for MM.

Still giving edge to Winston for fantasy purposes, but they both play in a QB friendly division

 

[TREFF]

Just to be clear, i do think marriota is a better QB, more likely to win a super bowl someday imho, but, fantasy wise, I'll take Winston

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I think it's pretty close between them. Evans is a really great target for Winston and Brate was good also and now they added to that. Mariota has that great offense line going for him, Murray and Walker (declining but still effective) with Mathews ( who became a decent threat) and the Titians also added some weapons.
Winston turnovers are alarmingly high with 18 interceptions vs 9 for Mariota. So think the Bucs will try to cut those down by running the ball more if they are able ( might have to wait until Martin gets back) bringing in Howard will help, because he's known as a good blocking TE ( obviously also known for his catching abilities)
I slightly favor Mariota, but would be happy with either.

 

[SteelersPride]

hasn't mariota iutscored winston regardless of the weapons @TREFF

 

[TREFF]

hasn't mariota iutscored winston regardless of the weapons @TREFF

Weapons aren't the same any longer, if they were, they'd be more equal in my book, and if either miss time, my money is on Marriota.

Djax >>>> any unproven rookie for an entire offenses ' outlook

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Weapons aren't the same any longer, if they were, they'd be more equal in my book, and if either miss time, my money is on Marriota.

Djax >>>> any unproven rookie for an entire offenses ' outlook

You forgetting about Decker?

 

[SteelersPride]

Weapons aren't the same any longer, if they were, they'd be more equal in my book, and if either miss time, my money is on Marriota.

Djax >>>> any unproven rookie for an entire offenses ' outlook

yeah i dunno mariota outplayed winston with less already, adddjng djax and a rook tight end isn't life altering

 

[TREFF]

yeah i dunno mariota outplayed winston with less already, adddjng djax and a rook tight end isn't life altering

I think he sure could be, offenses work better Edith him in the lineup, the Redskins went from mediocre to Madden on rookie level output, Eagles had a good drop when he left..Kirk Cousins, the definition of mediocre QB skills, is on the verge of the highest contract ever after operating in an offense opened up by him

 

[TREFF]

You forgetting about Decker?

I did, but after i remembered him, i remembered he's getting older and coming off a hip injury, not gonna put a lot of stock in him

 

[SteelersPride]

I did, but after i remembered him, i remembered he's getting older and coming off a hip injury, not gonna put a lot of stock in him

why cant he recover from. the hip? everyone else can recover??

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I did, but after i remembered him, i remembered he's getting older and coming off a hip injury, not gonna put a lot of stock in him

Thought Decker and Jackson were the same age and speaking of injuries, what the over/ under that Jackson misses some games?

 

[TKOSpikes]

Both will be too expensive for me, but in a vacuum I'd take .................. flip a coin.

 

[SteelersPride]

Thought Decker and Jackson were the same age and speaking of injuries, what the over/ under that Jackson misses some games?

yup, and if charles is ok after blowing his knees 283763 times decker can do one hip. i don't get how it's ok for one guy but not others on the injury front

 

[Gatorchip]

 

[TREFF]

yup, and if charles is ok after blowing his knees 283763 times decker can do one hip. i don't get how it's ok for one guy but not others on the injury front

because Charles is still better than CJ, Decker operates well within a system, he doesn't define the system, so his addition, while nice, is no huge factor. . he might steal away his numbers from what was already there, he's not creating much for those around him. Jackson opens up 3/4's of the field