IDP trade question. Need the boys help on this one.

[The Foot]

Guy what group of players would you want on your team for this season coming up.

Side A

Aaron Donald
Tavon Austin
Dion Lewis
James White

Side B

Jeremy Langford
Travis Benjamin
Rashard Jennings
Andre Williams
Coby Fleener
Aqib Talib
Mike Daniels

@TREFF @Barilko @HaroldSeattle @averagejoe @leftypower @Sam Sportboy @tlance @TKOSpikes @canesandfinsfanatic @Yellow Fuzzies @Ram Tough and anyone else i forgot

 

[The Foot]

oh side be add short to it

Guy what group of players would you want on your team for this season coming up.

Side A

Aaron Donald
Tavon Austin
Dion Lewis
James White

Side B

Kawann short
Jeremy Langford
Travis Benjamin
Rashard Jennings
Andre Williams
Coby Fleener
Aqib Talib
Mike Daniels

@TREFF@Barilko@HaroldSeattle@averagejoe@leftypower@Sam Sportboy@tlance@TKOSpikes@canesandfinsfanatic@Yellow Fuzzies@Ram Tough and anyone else i forgot

 

[Bandit]

oh side be add short to it

Guy what group of players would you want on your team for this season coming up.

Side A

Aaron Donald
Tavon Austin
Dion Lewis
James White

Side B

Kawann short
Jeremy Langford
Travis Benjamin
Rashard Jennings
Andre Williams
Coby Fleener
Aqib Talib
Mike Daniels

@TREFF@Barilko@HaroldSeattle@averagejoe@leftypower@Sam Sportboy@tlance@TKOSpikes@canesandfinsfanatic@Yellow Fuzzies@Ram Tough and anyone else i forgot

I'd take side B. If it's PPR it's closer because of Lewis but I'd still rather have side B

 

[TREFF]

Side A easily for me, B Seems like a whole lot of fluff and not enough beef. If your looking for some quality depth, B has it. If you liking for quality every week starters, it's A

 

[SoShady]

Taking out the fluff..

Donald, Lewis for Langford, Benjamin and Fleener

You can argue the RB's are a wash. I have a hard time trusting a Pats RB even then he can put up some solid PPR numbers. Many are down on Langford and feel like Howard will steal touches.

Does team A have a desperate need for a TE? Does that owner think things will finally click for him with Brees?

Donald is the only worthwhile IDP in the trade. A elite option at that especially if league has DT. Benjamin would only be a spot start bye week guy unless it's a huge league.

I would side with team A if they already have a quality starting TE.

 

[averagejoe]

Honestly, if it were my deal, I would take side A.

What ruins the deal for me is the 4 vs 8 tradeoff.
Treff hits the nail on the head.

But if I was getting A, I'd be glad that I was getting less players but more quality.
If I was supposed to get the players in B, I "reject" the offer just based on the mismatch of numbers.

But that's just me.

 

[tlance]

I would never accept an 8 for 4 if I were getting the 8. That person would have to cut 4 players just to make this deal happen. I have never had a team with 4 droppable players in it.

I think B's side would actually be more attractive than it is if a couple players were subtracted.

 

[TREFF]

It's funny, generally I can tell what side of the deal Foot is on just based on the players involved. This one has some of his beloved on both sides though.

I'm guessing he's on the Donaldson side, but only becuase he previously had a Q involving Ronaldinho

 

[The Foot]

Yeah thanks guys I have the Donald side and was offered the short side. I didn't love the deal but figured I would let you guys see of you thought otherwise

 

[SmokingMonkey]

agree with side A - always take to side with the studs, if possible.

But, in dynasty, I could see a situation where you might want to add depth for the starters you have.

Sneaky good player on your side is Tavon Austin.
Loved that pick of yours in the suicide league, Rams seemed to finally commit to getting him touches last year, and he performed well. Gurley in the fold should make that end around even nastier, as I can't imagine too many safeties or linebackers won't bite on the fake hand off after 10 straight Gurley rushes.

 

[Barilko]

Well Foot the boys certainly spelt that out for you and rather clearly
im mean 8 for 4 who ya cutting...

who in the 8 do you like

Benj maybe if Allen is healthy he could make for a nice 1 2 punch with Rivers chucking it

 

[SteelersPride]

Side b, BC everyone says sude A