Quick trade question, need all the big boys help on this one

[The Foot]

Side a gets: LARRY Fitzgerald, doug Martin/Charles sims

Side b gets: Carlos Hyde.

This is a full keeper and you keep your guys forever all of them.

Thoughts, which side you want

 

[femurov]

I will help, even though I am trying to lose some weight and I don't appreciate your title.

I think we need your scoring and starting requirements for this, but I lean towards the Fitz/Tampa side. Hyde has shown flashes of being able to be a full time back, but hasn't been able to stay healthy enough to put it all together. He could change teams soon and end up in a great situation or a crowded backfield. If I were giving up Fitz, I would aim for a RB with better upside or a more proven commodity. If I were giving up Hyde, I may aim for a younger WR that has a chance to be a solid starter for the next few years.

This is the type of trade where I would like to see the rosters to see what each team is trying to accomplish.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

This is not a future trade at all. And for that reason I will go with the fitz side.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Yeah I'll go with the Fitz/Martin side. Hyde hasn't had a season that he's really produced and been a boon for his owners, Fitz/ Martin have had those seasons and I trust them way more then Hyde.

 

[The Foot]

I will help, even though I am trying to lose some weight and I don't appreciate your title.

I think we need your scoring and starting requirements for this, but I lean towards the Fitz/Tampa side. Hyde has shown flashes of being able to be a full time back, but hasn't been able to stay healthy enough to put it all together. He could change teams soon and end up in a great situation or a crowded backfield. If I were giving up Fitz, I would aim for a RB with better upside or a more proven commodity. If I were giving up Hyde, I may aim for a younger WR that has a chance to be a solid starter for the next few years.

This is the type of trade where I would like to see the rosters to see what each team is trying to accomplish.

Well I actually own fitz side. My thinking is fitz won't be around too much longer Ang Tampa kind of has a crowded backfield now. I like how shanahan us Freeman and the other rb and Im thinking hyde could benifit plus i always like hyde.

 

[tlance]

I think Fitz will be productive longer than Hyde will.

This is a huge overpay for Hyde. For one thing, I would prefer your TB duo over Hyde unless you could get Williams too. Joe Williams is getting that job before too long.

 

[Sam Sportboy]

Side a gets: LARRY Fitzgerald, doug Martin/Charles sims

Side b gets: Carlos Hyde.

This is a full keeper and you keep your guys forever all of them.

Thoughts, which side you want

Funny thing..............Martin may have fucked himself out of the rest of his career, but without looking it up I'm sure there is still a lot of tread on the tires...............same with Hyde actually.............I'd just keep my guise if I was you

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

I like the Martin/Fitz side of this deal-

 

[averagejoe]

As a Hyde owner in D2, I'm not having a warm fuzzy feeling about him.

But a lot of that has to do with the teases we see in the news feeds.
One week it's reported that the new staff is in a "wait and see" mode.
Another report says he doesn't fit Shanny's system.
Then you get a report that he's getting all the first team reps.

All these beat writers are spewing their opinions. I don't know what to believe. Really.
I almost hope they trade Hyde to a team that needs a RB.
But I doubt that happens too since Hightower is 31. And Joe Williams is a rookie with plenty to learn.
Just based on Hightower's age and Williams' learning curve, they need Hyde.
How much is anyone's guess.

 

[SteelersPride]

side a,

 

[Trudem]

As a Hyde owner in D2, I'm not having a warm fuzzy feeling about him.

But a lot of that has to do with the teases we see in the news feeds.
One week it's reported that the new staff is in a "wait and see" mode.
Another report says he doesn't fit Shanny's system.
Then you get a report that he's getting all the first team reps.

All these beat writers are spewing their opinions. I don't know what to believe. Really.
I almost hope they trade Hyde to a team that needs a RB.
But I doubt that happens too since Hightower is 31. And Joe Williams is a rookie with plenty to learn.
Just based on Hightower's age and Williams' learning curve, they need Hyde.
How much is anyone's guess.

I agree with this.

 

[The Foot]

Thanks for the help guys. You've talked me out of it.

 

[The Foot]

Or maybe I'll try and get more

 

[beantownmaniac]

Fitz alone is worth it IMO........And it's just long term baby fat!!

 

[SteelersPride]

def fitz side

 

[tlance]

As a Hyde owner in D2, I'm not having a warm fuzzy feeling about him.

But a lot of that has to do with the teases we see in the news feeds.
One week it's reported that the new staff is in a "wait and see" mode.
Another report says he doesn't fit Shanny's system.
Then you get a report that he's getting all the first team reps.

All these beat writers are spewing their opinions. I don't know what to believe. Really.
I almost hope they trade Hyde to a team that needs a RB.
But I doubt that happens too since Hightower is 31. And Joe Williams is a rookie with plenty to learn.
Just based on Hightower's age and Williams' learning curve, they need Hyde.
How much is anyone's guess.

I think it isn't a good time to trade for Hyde, but only because his price tag should be really low. Everyone expects him to lose the job.

The cost Foot would be paying here would make sense if he were returning a top 30 to 40 veteran player. Hyde is not that.