DCFFL 2017 Mock Comment Thread

[Shoeshine Boy]

Most accurate draft: 49ers (players selected in mock went on average 1.6 spots lower IRL)

Best draft for value: Chargers (players selected in mock went on average 19+ spots higher IRL)

Worst draft for value: Cardinals (players selected in mock went on average 48+ spots lower IRL)

 

[Draft Crazy]

Those are some pretty impressive stats.

What about players selected by right team but not right pick?

 

[Draft Crazy]

Shoeshine boy? Are you Underdog from KFFL?

 

[Shoeshine Boy]

Ya dude I thought you knew that lolol

 

[Shoeshine Boy]

What about players selected by right team but not right pick?

Haven't checked that one yet, will let you know

 

[Shoeshine Boy]

Besides Garrett, Barnett, and Basham, the following players were also selected in the real draft by the same team that selected them in the mock:

Solomon Thomas, 49ers (2 in the mock, 3 IRL)
Carl Lawson, Bengals (41, 116)
Julién Davenport, Texans (89, 130)
Taywan Taylor, Titans (100, 72)
Jaleel Johnson, Vikings (120, 109)
Isaiah Ford, Dolphins (184, 237)

 

[Shoeshine Boy]

OK so I just went back and plugged in the numbers on the last version of the scoring system that I had evolved over the years on KFFL and actually under that system Indy comes up with the best score...even though the 9ers picks overall were closer on average, the Colts GM was more consistently close from pick to pick, which yielded a better grade for overall accuracy (e.g, the Pumphrey and Asiata picks were off by +66 and -55 so they're pretty close to neutral in a straight average of the whole group, but hurt the grades for those individual picks).

So under my not so super-secret formula for grading the mock, (which as I always note emphasizes accuracy, but I will give teams who do a good job drafting for value the occasional bump up), here are my 2017 DCFFL grades:

Colts A
49ers A
Seahawks A-
Chiefs A-
Panthers A-
Chargers A-
Jets A-
Cowboys A-
Giants B+
Bears B+
Steelers B+
Vikings B+
Texans B
Patriots B
Raiders B
Bengals B
Eagles B
Lions B
Titans B
Broncos B
Packers B-
Bills B-
Dolphins B-
Jaguars B-
Browns B-
Falcons B-
Rams C+
Saints C+
Buccaneers C+
Ravens C
Cardinals C
Redskins C

 

[Draft Crazy]

Thank you!