#1 Voted by the Players

[NWPATSFAN]

So the players voted Tom Brady the best player in the league last season. For those of us NE fans it's ho hum another day at the office. So what do the haters have to say? Is this enough to have @DirtDirtDirt disappear again?

Personally I thought the players would vote A Rog. Glad to be wrong for once.

 

[TJL]

He's the goat

 

[SteelersPride]

So the players voted Tom Brady the best player in the league last season. For those of us NE fans it's ho hum another day at the office. So what do the haters have to say? Is this enough to have @DirtDirtDirt disappear again?

Personally I thought the players would vote A Rog. Glad to be wrong for once.

Hes the GOAT, and u spent a few hours crying into your pillow, staring at your brady fat head, pretty standard day for all pats fans

 

[batchaps4me]

So the players voted Tom Brady the best player in the league last season. For those of us NE fans it's ho hum another day at the office. So what do the haters have to say? Is this enough to have @DirtDirtDirt disappear again?

Personally I thought the players would vote A Rog. Glad to be wrong for once.

What the hell would the players know??? Especially those dumb ass linemen!!!














End sarcasm.

 

[YankeeRebel]

What the hell would the players know??? Especially those dumb ass linemen!!!














End sarcasm.

Wow or dumb ass posters, linemen are traditionally the smartest players in the league.

 

[batchaps4me]

Wow or dumb ass posters, linemen are traditionally the smartest players in the league.

You missed the "End Sarcasm" at the bottom of my post.

 

[YankeeRebel]

You missed the "End Sarcasm" at the bottom of my post.

I apologize.

 

[batchaps4me]

I apologize.

No problem, sir. I was, and am a jackass along with a dumb assed posting history!!! I did it on purpose.

 

[Bridgeburner]

So the players voted Tom Brady the best player in the league last season. For those of us NE fans it's ho hum another day at the office. So what do the haters have to say? Is this enough to have @DirtDirtDirt disappear again?

Personally I thought the players would vote A Rog. Glad to be wrong for once.

The list is complete shit. A total joke. But at least they got the top spot right.

 

[Thruthefog]

Matt Millen was a player.

 

[packerzrule]

The list is complete shit. A total joke. But at least they got the top spot right.

so who is your top 10??

 

[Bridgeburner]

so who is your top 10??

I don't really know. I don't think about it much to be honest. But just perusing through the list and seeing certain names above other names I always chuckle.

 

[Bridgeburner]

A good question is how to correctly weigh the quarterbacks. For instance, Ben is in the 20s. Bell and Brown are top ten. Ben is far more important to the Steelers than either Brown or Bell. Should that factor in? I don't really know. It's one of the things that gives me pause.

 

[batchaps4me]

so who is your top 10??

I hate lists like this. It is too hard if not impossible to compare dominating players at different positions. Apples to oranges. I just looked at the top 20 and it is top heavy on O "skill positions" with only one lineman at 18. I know that it is easier to compare stats for QB/RB/WR but no lineman is better than the sixth best QB, give me a break.

 

[YankeeRebel]

I hate lists like this. It is too hard if not impossible to compare dominating players at different positions. Apples to oranges. I just looked at the top 20 and it is top heavy on O "skill positions" with only one lineman at 18. I know that it is easier to compare stats for QB/RB/WR but no lineman is better than the sixth best QB, give me a break.

It's the Heisman theory which gets it wrong almost every year. The best player in college football must be a QB, WR or RB almost never a defensive player and to my recollection never an O-Linemen, even though they are the primary reason the other three have flashy numbers. Heisman is a flipping embarrassment.

 

[batchaps4me]

It's the Heisman theory which gets it wrong almost every year. The best player in college football must be a QB, WR or RB almost never a defensive player and to my recollection never an O-Linemen, even though they are the primary reason the other three have flashy numbers. Heisman is a flipping embarrassment.

I owe you a beer .... well said!!!!

 

[packerzrule]

I hate lists like this. It is too hard if not impossible to compare dominating players at different positions. Apples to oranges. I just looked at the top 20 and it is top heavy on O "skill positions" with only one lineman at 18. I know that it is easier to compare stats for QB/RB/WR but no lineman is better than the sixth best QB, give me a break.

roger that - was surprised by that myself

on a related note - I was surfing and saw the tail end of the show where the 1-5 players were announced so decided to watch a bit of it. Who in the hell thought it would be a good idea to have Ike Taylor on this show? Christ Sake, Snoop Dog offered better commentary and insight than this illiterate fool

 

[rmilia1]

Vote was actually for best players heading into 2017 and not based solely on last year . Not sure how anyone other than Brady would've been number 1. 5 rings will do that lol

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

A good question is how to correctly weigh the quarterbacks. For instance, Ben is in the 20s. Bell and Brown are top ten. Ben is far more important to the Steelers than either Brown or Bell. Should that factor in? I don't really know. It's one of the things that gives me pause.

Seeing both Derek Carr & Dak Prescott ahead of Ben & Brees made me laugh the most.

 

[Bridgeburner]

Seeing both Derek Carr & Dak Prescott ahead of Ben made me laugh the most.

Seeing Dak ahead of about 30 other players made me laugh. Kid has a future, no doubt but lol.