Rodgers and Brady are the two best QBs of all time...

[purguy12]

Rodgers has the talent but he doesn't win enough. He chokes a lot. He always had weapons on offense.
Don't get me wrong Rodgers is great and one of the best but he isn't even in the Top 10 yet. Brady well that is a different story. He is already in the Top 3.

 

[GNG]

Or doing something that people would misconstrue at being a flaming homosexual

 

[packerzrule]

Rodgers has the talent but he doesn't win enough. He chokes a lot. He always had weapons on offense.
Don't get me wrong Rodgers is great and one of the best but he isn't even in the Top 10 yet. Brady well that is a different story. He is already in the Top 3.

how so??

splain Lucy

 

[GNG]

Rodgers has the talent but he doesn't win enough. He chokes a lot. He always had weapons on offense.
Don't get me wrong Rodgers is great and one of the best but he isn't even in the Top 10 yet. Brady well that is a different story. He is already in the Top 3.

Are you related to Skip Bayless?

 

[purguy12]

how so??

splain Lucy

1 Super bowl.

 

[purguy12]

Are you related to Skip Bayless?

Nope. I like Rodgers. I wish I had him on my team but people over react too much about Rodgers. He has 1 super bowl and only NFC champ once. lost in the 1st rd 3 times.

 

[GNG]

Nope. I like Rodgers. I wish I had him on my team but people over react too much about Rodgers. He has 1 super bowl and only NFC champ once. lost in the 1st rd 3 times.

Those losses had more to do with the Packer's poor defense and special team play than with Rodgers.

 

[GNG]

1 Super bowl.

Dan Marino never won a Super Bowl and I consider him a top 5 QB.

 

[purguy12]

I will say this about Rodgers he has all the tools and maybe more tools then any QB but he sometimes tries to do too much and that is why he hasn't won more. I don't want to hear he didn't have weapons. He always had Weapons. No excuses there. He just can't put it all together for a nice run. I would like to see him reach at least 2 more super bowls or 2 or 3 more NFC championship games.

More positive on Rodgers: This was one of the best runs I have seen from a QB.

So please don't think I hate Rodgers. I am very impressed with him and what he brings and his talents.

 

[purguy12]

Dan Marino never won a Super Bowl and I consider him a top 5 QB.

Different Era. NFC hasn't been that tough. Think about it there is no Big Ben or Brady in the NFC to get by. He is the best in the NFC. Its like LBJ playing in the East and only getting to the Finals once or twice in his career. early in his career he had Brees but that is about it.

 

[packerzrule]

1 Super bowl.

that does not equate to choking

look at the post season losses and tell me how many were on him vs how many was on the Packers defense

 

[purguy12]

U watch some of these debate shows and they talk about Rodgers and Brady and how some would pick Rodgers that is just insane. I think those people should get fired. brady by far is better then Rodgers because the #1 thing in sports is winning and Brady wins leads better. I mean he is in his 6 straight AFC championship game. Does anyone know How impressive that is. This year he is doing it with out his best offensive player Gronk.

Again this is no knock on Rodgers. He is great and is #2 in the league right now but Brady is by far above anyone else right now when it comes down to who u want in a playoff game and lead your team in the playoff.

 

[purguy12]

that does not equate to choking

look at the post season losses and tell me how many were on him vs how many was on the Packers defense

Well this last game he almost choked it away. He stopped scoring. He was 12-22 for 120 yards after the 1st Q.
He made a great throw and catch at the end. Maybe Choke was the wrong word.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Rodgers has the talent but he doesn't win enough. He chokes a lot. He always had weapons on offense.
Don't get me wrong Rodgers is great and one of the best but he isn't even in the Top 10 yet. Brady well that is a different story. He is already in the Top 3.

Nonsense, complete and total

To ignore the dog shit defenses the Packers have had, or onside kicks that couldn't be fielded

Tom Brady can play poorly (last Saturday) and the Patriots can win and win big

Aaron Rodgers plays poorly, the Packers don't stand a chance, not a chance

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

U watch some of these debate shows and they talk about Rodgers and Brady and how some would pick Rodgers that is just insane. I think those people should get fired. brady by far is better then Rodgers because the #1 thing in sports is winning and Brady wins leads better. I mean he is in his 6 straight AFC championship game. Does anyone know How impressive that is. This year he is doing it with out his best offensive player Gronk.

Again this is no knock on Rodgers. He is great and is #2 in the league right now but Brady is by far above anyone else right now when it comes down to who u want in a playoff game and lead your team in the playoff.

Ignoring all factors is silly

The awful division Brady plays in, the greatest coach in history Brady plays for, the typical Top 5-10 defenses the Pats have

So many factors go into winning and losing

Rodgers has lost playoff games 51-45 and 45-31 and so on and so on

 

[sonnyblack65]

Nonsense, complete and total

To ignore the dog shit defenses the Packers have had, or onside kicks that couldn't be fielded

Tom Brady can play poorly (last Saturday) and the Patriots can win and win big

Aaron Rodgers plays poorly, the Packers don't stand a chance, not a chance

Haha Brady to you is like shit to a fly, knew you'd come buzzing

 

[packerzrule]

Well this last game he almost choked it away. He stopped scoring. He was 12-22 for 120 yards after the 1st Q.
He made a great throw and catch at the end. Maybe Choke was the wrong word.

true, most of the damage was done in the first half - but the two drives late in the 4th to set up the field goals was not what you expect from a choker

 

[purguy12]

that does not equate to choking

look at the post season losses and tell me how many were on him vs how many was on the Packers defense

Ok I took a look.
Didn't do well against the Giants in 2011
Struggled against the 49ers in 2013
Bad game against Seattle in 2014.
not a great game against Arizona in 2015.
Overall its a team sport so yes it doesn't all fall on him. that I will admit.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Haha Brady to you is like shit to a fly, knew you'd come buzzing

“I think he does things that no one in the league has ever done, or can do, just because of his physical ability,” Brady said Monday morning during his weekly interview on sports radio WEEI (h/t Mike Reiss of ESPN). “Some of the plays he makes are just phenomenal.”


“I think he makes everything look so simple because he has such an efficient delivery,” Brady said on the program. “Everything really looks effortless with him, which is the amazing part. He’s definitely working hard, but he’s making hard look easy; it’s a very effortless style he plays with. The velocity of the ball, the placement of the ball, I mean, he’s just an incredible player. He works very hard at it, he’s a very talented player, and he’s just having an incredible season.”


“I always love watching his tape, admiring the things he can do, because I can’t do many of those things. … Whenever he’s on, I usually stay up and watch.”

 

[purguy12]

Ignoring all factors is silly

The awful division Brady plays in, the greatest coach in history Brady plays for, the typical Top 5-10 defenses the Pats have

So many factors go into winning and losing

Rodgers has lost playoff games 51-45 and 45-31 and so on and so on

LOL GB plays in a poor division. LOL When was the last time bears, Lions or Minn good. Long time. I mean actually good. AFC has been a tougher league for awhile now. Come on man. That throw that in this argument.

Brady has been fighting with Payton and Big Ben for years now. Rodgers early on had Brees but that is it.