MLB- Bobby Bonds
NFL - OJ Simpson (or if I need to pick someone not suspected of double murder, Barry Sanders)
NBA - George Gervin (I wish I could say Darryl Dawkins or Dr J but they both played for the home team. I'm pretty sure if he was on another team, Dawkins would be my favorite)
NHL -Brian Trottier - tough one for some reason. I have a hard time not hating opposing players in this sport for some reason, but I at least have to respect Trottier.
MLB: Giancarlo Stanton
NBA: Allen Iverson
NFL: Teddy Bridgewater (never been to an NFL game so I'm going with a college game I watched)
NHL: Only been to 1 and it was the team I liked so I got nothing here.