Who's Your Top 25 After Week 6

[Judge Fudge]

Copied yours tee, Haven't done these in a while so bare with me. Of course i listen to arguments and will adjust if needed.

1. Georgia
2. Iowa
3. Cincinnati
4. Alabama
5. Penn State
6. Oregon
7. Ohio State
8. Oklahoma (My Argument is the same Buckeye made)
9. Michigan
10. Michigan State
11. Oklahoma State
12. Ole Miss
13. Notre Dame
14. Coastal Carolina
15. Kentucky
16. Texas A&M
17. Wake Forest
18. Arkansas
19. Arizona State
20. Florida
21. SMU
22. NC State
23. San Diego State
24. UTSA
25. Baylor

 

[Judge Fudge]

Here the thing.

If Cincy Makes it to be promised land....

They are playing most likely either Georgia or Iowa, who both are Defensive Juggernauts.

And their a one trick pony, granted a good trick pony, so it will be like a cow being lead to slaughter.

 

[PIBuckeye]

Copied yours tee, Haven't done these in a while so bare with me. Of course i listen to arguments and will adjust if needed.

1. Georgia
2. Iowa
3. Cincinnati
4. Alabama
5. Penn State
6. Oregon
7. Ohio State
8. Oklahoma (My Argument is the same Buckeye made)
9. Michigan
10. Michigan State
11. Oklahoma State
12. Ole Miss
13. Notre Dame
14. Coastal Carolina
15. Kentucky
16. Texas A&M
17. Wake Forest
18. Arkansas
19. Arizona State
20. Florida
21. SMU
22. NC State
23. San Diego State
24. UTSA
25. Baylor

This is very close to mine. on the OU argument.

one question.

A #3 team lost to a #12 team by only one score. 7 pts. The #12 team jumped to #3, the former #3 dropped to #9. ok, fine.

The #1 team, lost to an unranked team. #1 team only drops to #4? really? many high ranked teams that lost to unranked, dropped much farther. Why the exception here??

 

[Judge Fudge]

This is very close to mine. on the OU argument.

one question.

A #3 team lost to a #12 team by only one score. 7 pts. The #12 team jumped to #3, the former #3 dropped to #9. ok, fine.

The #1 team, lost to an unranked team. #1 team only drops to #4? really? many high ranked teams that lost to unranked, dropped much farther. Why the exception here??

I was making this Argument in A and M/ Bama game thread.

Gimme a sec....

True and I shouldn't be pleading Bama case because I spit on the ground they walk on but...

They have beaten 3 ranked teams before this. Florida, Mississippi and ?????? I can't remember but swear it wasn't Miami

 

[PIBuckeye]

I was making this Argument in A and M/ Bama game thread.

Gimme a sec....

yea, I don't think that matters. or should. Miami is long gone. They never should have been ranked where they were. and Florida isn't any big fish this year.

and back to my original statement. They lost to an unranked team. end of story. I think they should be somewhere 9-11.

I again, have to say that bama is getting preferential treatment. other programs in the same situation would've dropped further.