Who are the five most overrated QB's/Teams in the NFL?

[DaBearsShowPride]

Plenty of time? That's insane.

And saying he's a "bad" QB because he isn't as good as Brady, Manning or Rodgers means every QB not named Rodgers, Manning or Brady is a bad QB.

Exactly and I will say this again to JDM, have you watched every single down Cutler has played in since he joined the Bears? JDM's explanation for Cutler being bad is everything I have heard in the media and on Sportscenter. NEWS FLASH: The media will say anything they feel is correct in their eyes.

 

[JDM]

Plenty of time? That's insane.

And saying he's a "bad" QB because he isn't as good as Brady, Manning or Rodgers means every QB not named Rodgers, Manning or Brady is a bad QB.

That was in response to his claim no one would have done better. It isn't real. And there have been plays where he's made mistakes with no pressure whatsoever at the time. He doesn't make good decisions, time or not. He is a middle of the pack QB. Nothing more, and certainly not the player bans fans continue to try to make him out to be.

 

[JDM]

Exactly and I will say this again to JDM, have you watched every single down Cutler has played in since he joined the Bears? JDM's explanation for Cutler being bad is everything I have heard in the media and on Sportscenter. NEWS FLASH: The media will say anything they feel is correct in their eyes.

I don't watch espn. I watch the games and make my own conclusions.

 

[broncosmitty]

This guy actually thinks Jay Cutler is a quality NFL QB, that's funny. The dude fucking sucks man, get real.

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

I don't watch espn. I watch the games and make my own conclusions.

So let me ask you for the 3rd or 4th time since I havent received an answer. Have you watched every single snap of Cutler since he has been with the Bears?

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

This guy actually thinks Jay Cutler is a quality NFL QB, that's funny. The dude fucking sucks man, get real.

This is hilarious coming from a Lions fan haha. Ya so what Stafford puts up better stats, Cutler has more wins then him and Stafford chokes hard and it happens very often.

 

[JDM]

So let me ask you for the 3rd or 4th time since I havent received an answer. Have you watched every single snap of Cutler since he has been with the Bears?

I have seen a solid majority of them. I doubt I have seen all of them. I have more than enough of a sample size to judge on.

 

[broncosmitty]

I don't remember bringing up Stafford, but he sure does throw for more yards. Doesnt throw his teammates under the bus. Appears to be interested during games. Doesn't get his head coach fired..... Why in the world would a Bears fan think Jay is good? He's the biggest stepping stone your franchise has. Rex Grossman didn't fuck up enough that you guys actually made a Super Bowl with him under center. It's not your line, your receivers, your Tight Ends, Martz, Lovie... It won't be Tressman either, the problem was-is-and will be Cutler. I hope he has many more disappointing seasons for you guys on the other side of the lake.

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

I have seen a solid majority of them. I doubt I have seen all of them. I have more than enough of a sample size to judge on.

A sample size compared to 5 years is a joke.

 

[broncosmitty]

So let me ask you for the 3rd or 4th time since I havent received an answer. Have you watched every single snap of Cutler since he has been with the Bears?

Like you've watched every snap... Everybody has to piss, flip burgers, check out cheerleaders, etc. Face facts man, your QB is a bottom half starter, with a strong arm and sugar.

 

[JDM]

A sample size compared to 5 years is a joke.

A sample size of most of the snaps of most of the games. I just said that.

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

I don't remember bringing up Stafford, but he sure does throw for more yards. Doesnt throw his teammates under the bus. Appears to be interested during games. Doesn't get his head coach fired..... Why in the world would a Bears fan think Jay is good? He's the biggest stepping stone your franchise has. Rex Grossman didn't fuck up enough that you guys actually made a Super Bowl with him under center. It's not your line, your receivers, your Tight Ends, Martz, Lovie... It won't be Tressman either, the problem was-is-and will be Cutler. I hope he has many more disappointing seasons for you guys on the other side of the lake.

I brought up Stafford because you brought up Cutler and I laughed at it becomes it came from a Lions fan. This is another person who takes the media WAY TO SERIOUS and you know nothing about the actual situation that is going on. Clearly Grossman was the reason they got to the Super Bowl and of course we have had the best offensive line, wr's, te's and coaching staff to go along with our Offensive minded coach Lovie Smith.......

 

[JDM]

Stafford has better physical tools and better mental ones.

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

Like you've watched every snap... Everybody has to piss, flip burgers, check out cheerleaders, etc. Face facts man, your QB is a bottom half starter, with a strong arm and sugar.

Yes I have watched every single snap Cutler has been in since joining the Bears. Some people piss during timeouts, flip burgers during half time and sorry I pay attention to football not Cheerleaders. I have not once said Cutler is an elite QB and he deserves to be in the middle of the pact but he does not suck nearly as bad as people make him out to be. I would take Cutler anyday over Stafford, he at least wins.

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

Stafford has better physical tools and better mental ones.

I would agree on the mental note of that but Cutler has all the physical tools that Stafford has.

 

[NinerSickness]

Stafford has better physical tools and better mental ones.

Stafford hasn't shown anywhere near the chops Cutler has yet. Stafford's young & still getting better (or at least Lions' fans hope he is because he played sucktastically last season). But Cutler has proven he can be a good QB if he has some time to throw the ball.

I hope Cutler leaves Chicago next season so he can prove what he can do. Put him on a good offense and he'll do great. If I were the Cardinals, I would draft one of those great LTs in the 2014 draft and then trade whatever it took to get Cutler in Arizona if / when Chicago franchises him. I would've said "Cardinals or Cowboys," but the Cowboys stupidly gave Romo a huge extension; ad they're stuck with him.

The Bengals, Browns or Buccs would be smart to go after him too. I'd say Jacksonville as well, but they're about as big of an offensive disaster as Chicago.

 

[JDM]

Yes I have watched every single snap Cutler has been in since joining the Bears. Some people piss during timeouts, flip burgers during half time and sorry I pay attention to football not Cheerleaders. I have not once said Cutler is an elite QB and he deserves to be in the middle of the pact but he does not suck nearly as bad as people make him out to be. I would take Cutler anyday over Stafford, he at least wins.

I said he was middle of the pack. He's better than Kevin Kolb but he's not better than Alex smith

 

[JDM]

Stafford hasn't shown anywhere near the chops Cutler has yet. Stafford's young & still getting better (or at least Lions' fans hope he is because he played sucktastically last season). But Cutler has proven he can be a good QB if he has some time to throw the ball.

I hope Cutler leaves Chicago next season so he can prove what he can do. Put him on a good offense and he'll do great. If I were the Cardinals, I would draft one of those great LTs in the 2014 draft and then trade whatever it took to get Cutler in Arizona if / when Chicago franchises him. I would've said "Cardinals or Cowboys," but the Cowboys stupidly gave Romo a huge extension; ad they're stuck with him.

The Bengals, Browns or Buccs would be smart to go after him too. I'd say Jacksonville as well, but they're about as big of an offensive disaster as Chicago.

Cutler has never proved he can be a good QB. He has had the physical tools but never came near the mental ones.

 

[broncosmitty]

Yes I have watched every single snap Cutler has been in since joining the Bears. Some people piss during timeouts, flip burgers during half time and sorry I pay attention to football not Cheerleaders. I have not once said Cutler is an elite QB and he deserves to be in the middle of the pact but he does not suck nearly as bad as people make him out to be. I would take Cutler anyday over Stafford, he at least wins.

If you'd take Cutler over Stafford you clearly aren't watching enough football. Which might seem impossible, but you're obviously missing something, as Cutler wouldn't start for many teams. (Clev, Jax, Buff, Oak, ummm yeah not many)

 

[broncosmitty]

I said he was middle of the pack. He's better than Kevin Kolb but he's not better than Alex smith

Alex Smith by far a better QB. Arm strength is about all Jay has going for him, IMO.