Game Thread: WFT vs the bengals preseason 2

[countryroads316]

Sims dropped easy catch

 

[skinsdad62]

 

[skinsdad62]

Sims dropped easy catch

The shit that gets you cut

 

[skinsdad62]

Haven’t seen dean tonight , miss him

 

[Sportster 72]

Sims with alligator arms

 

[countryroads316]

Patterson may have took Carters and Sims spot because he can do it all

 

[skinsdad62]

 

[skinsdad62]

 

[skinsdad62]

 

[skinsdad62]

 

[skinsdad62]

 

[skinsdad62]

The defense has done pretty darn well

 

[deanpet21]

This is why I cant see him making this team unless he wins the return battle. I think Patterson will be our returner and 4th RB, and AGG will be the #6 WR. If the 6th WR is not the returner, AGG should be the favorite. Thoughts?

 

[gkekoa]

This is why I cant see him making this team unless he wins the return battle. I think Patterson will be our returner and 4th RB, and AGG will be the #6 WR. If the 6th WR is not the returner, AGG should be the favorite. Thoughts?

I think WR outside the top three could be any combination of Humphries, Cam, AGG, Sims, Milne or Carter.

Humphries has done nothing. 1 catch, 6 yards, 5 targets
Cam with a fumble last night but good otherwise.
AGG finally caught something. It doesn’t excuse alligator arms against NE and missed assignments.
Milne is a better receiver than Carter and has done just as well on PR.
Carter has done nothing.

 

[deanpet21]

I think WR outside the top three could be any combination of Humphries, Cam, AGG, Sims, Milne or Carter.

Humphries has done nothing. 1 catch, 6 yards, 5 targets
Cam with a fumble last night but good otherwise.
AGG finally caught something. It doesn’t excuse alligator arms against NE and missed assignments.
Milne is a better receiver than Carter and has done just as well on PR.
Carter has done nothing.

Miline making the final 53 would be a huge longshot. I just dont see that happening.
Humphries did better against NE than last night. FWIW, Fitz over threw him on a TD. Can't blame Humphries for that.
Cam should of got in on that TD.
There is no way Miline has the edge over Carter when it comes to PR. The question is, is Miline a better WR than Agg right now?
It comes down to PR and if the team really wants AGG to make this roster. If they let Paterson do PR then Agg becomes the 6th WR. If Carter wins the PR job then he has to be the 6th Wr no matter his skill level at WR. I dont see us keeping 7WR's.

 

[skinsdad62]

Miline making the final 53 would be a huge longshot. I just dont see that happening.
Humphries did better against NE than last night. FWIW, Fitz over threw him on a TD. Can't blame Humphries for that.
Cam should of got in on that TD.
There is no way Miline has the edge over Carter when it comes to PR. The question is, is Miline a better WR than Agg right now?
It comes down to PR and if the team really wants AGG to make this roster. If they let Paterson do PR then Agg becomes the 6th WR. If Carter wins the PR job then he has to be the 6th Wr no matter his skill level at WR. I dont see us keeping 7WR's.

JP has never fielded a punt in any type of organized football . he isnt the guy to be PR
Milne and carter are even as returners and wrs in my opinion
AGG is where sims was 2 yrs ago (shaky ) and AGG has to beat out sims
milne would have to beat out humphries , ( i dont see it yet )
carter would have to beat out humphries (i dont see it )

 

[gkekoa]

Miline making the final 53 would be a huge longshot. I just dont see that happening.

I agree but it could easily happen.

Milne- 2 receptions for 16 yards on four targets. 1 PR for 19 yards.
Sims- 1 catch for 18 yards on 2 targets.
Carter- 1 catch for -1 yard on 2 targets. 19 yard average against NE but only 7 against the Bengals. He quite literally brings nothing to the table.

Humphries did better against NE than last night. FWIW, Fitz over threw him on a TD. Can't blame Humphries for that.

Humphries was ass against NE. 1 catch for 6 yards on 2 targets. He had zero catches in three targets against the Bengals.

Cam should of got in on that TD.

Should he? Sadly I can’t find the play. Sims had plenty of room outside where the ball was thrown too close to the sideline. When he caught the ball it was centered on his body, he was in the air, and momentum and a push made him land OB.

There is no way Miline has the edge over Carter when it comes to PR. The question is, is Miline a better WR than Agg right now?

Again, you look at PR in a vacuum. If Carter were Devin Hester…sure. He is not…he is average at best. In this preseason, Milne has been better than Carter as a PR.

It comes down to PR and if the team really wants AGG to make this roster. If they let Paterson do PR then Agg becomes the 6th WR. If Carter wins the PR job then he has to be the 6th Wr no matter his skill level at WR. I dont see us keeping 7WR's.

The PR is not really a job. It is a role that can be filled suitably by Milne or Sims, both of which are better WRs than Carter.

 

[deanpet21]

JP has never fielded a punt in any type of organized football . he isnt the guy to be PR
Milne and carter are even as returners and wrs in my opinion
AGG is where sims was 2 yrs ago (shaky ) and AGG has to beat out sims
milne would have to beat out humphries , ( i dont see it yet )
carter would have to beat out humphries (i dont see it )

I think AH is a lock. I think Carter gets the 6th WR slot. I have to come to terms that C. Sims will make it over AGG.

 

[gkekoa]

I think AH is a lock. I think Carter gets the 6th WR slot. I have to come to terms that C. Sims will make it over AGG.

Again…why is Humphries a lock? No separation. No chemistry. A catch percentage of 20%. 6 yards per reception. These numbers are beyond bad…they are compete ass.

 

[deanpet21]

Again…why is Humphries a lock? No separation. No chemistry. A catch percentage of 20%. 6 yards per reception. These numbers are beyond bad…they are compete ass.

Fine make a friendly bet. Does AH make this team? I think they brought him in here to be a 3rd down specialist.