Trade Thoughts? Roddy vs Tate etc...

[DUB]

Here is my team in a 12 team league:

Starters Normally
Rodgers
Fred
Oliver
E. Sanders
Randall Cobb
Flex (rb or wr) A. Brown
Donnell
Parkey
DEF

Bench
Bishop
Rainey
Stevan Ridley
T. West
Golden Tate
Alfred Blue

Trade is Golden Tate & Stevan Ridley for Ahmad Bradshaw & Roddy White.

In my mind this is a big toss up but like any trade taking in injuries post history and current history, team schedule, teams coaching style and winning attitude, etc... I'm factoring in everything and not seeing a clear cut winner in the trade. How about the genius minds on this board????

thx

-DUB-

 

[TKOSpikes]

Ehh. Not guaranteed improvements there. Ridley, frustrating or not can be a major factor and could easily finish better than the fragile Bradshaw. Roddy vs Tate is pretty much a preference toss up. I like Roddy more, but wouldn't argue with the guy who likes Tate.

 

[DUB]

Spikes, heck of a job the bills are doing. As you know bills fans are all over the country so I've made a lot of friends of their fans over the years, you guys are in heaven right now!! hahaha


-DUB-

 

[leftypower]

It's probably just me but I think the Ridley/Tate combo is the better of the two. With megatron banged up Tate is going to be the guy (for a couple of games anyway). Roddy is not bad but a bit up and down the last couple of years plus he seems to get nicked up more often than not. Ridley vs Bradshaw is a pretty even since you never know from one week to the next what role they will play - so I'd side with the guy with better health.