Too many RB's

[deanpet21]

if he beats them out its because he is better . RR didnt draft him

Right but RR brought JD and barber in.

 

[skinsdad62]

Right but RR brought JD and barber in.

so what , he brought in camp fodder

 

[deanpet21]

so what , he brought in camp fodder

Im saying there is no allegiance to Love b/c he is a 4th rounder and he didn't draft him.

 

[gkekoa]

What I want is Guice, Gibson, JD, and Barber. What will probably happen is AP, Guice, Gibson and JD.

So you don’t even want Love, who was a potential first rounder? I am not understanding your logic. JD, who has not done a damn thing in the league and doesn’t deserve to go by two initials, and Barber can be found on the street. Love is potentially a star.

 

[deanpet21]

So you don’t even want Love, who was a potential first rounder? I am not understanding your logic. JD, who has not done a damn thing in the league and doesn’t deserve to go by two initials, and Barber can be found on the street. Love is potentially a star.

Potentially a star. We dont know. JD is a better receiver than Love. Barber has played and can be a 3rd down back. Love brings nothing to the table right now. Now if he impresses in TC then thats a different story. I would list Gibson as a WR and the Rb's be Guice, Jd, Barber, and Love. No need for Ap to be on this team. Gibson should be teh 5th WR/RB for this team. We dont have to designate him as just a RB.

 

[skinsdad62]

Potentially a star. We dont know. JD is a better receiver than Love. Barber has played and can be a 3rd down back. Love brings nothing to the table right now. Now if he impresses in TC then thats a different story. I would list Gibson as a WR and the Rb's be Guice, Jd, Barber, and Love. No need for Ap to be on this team. Gibson should be teh 5th WR/RB for this team. We dont have to designate him as just a RB.

here is the thing we do know JD and barber are not stars

 

[gkekoa]

Potentially a star. We dont know. JD is a better receiver than Love. Barber has played and can be a 3rd down back. Love brings nothing to the table right now. Now if he impresses in TC then thats a different story. I would list Gibson as a WR and the Rb's be Guice, Jd, Barber, and Love. No need for Ap to be on this team. Gibson should be teh 5th WR/RB for this team. We dont have to designate him as just a RB.

Is JD a better receiver or has he just been given more opportunities to be so? From there, is he a better receiver than Gibson because that is JD’s actual competition. Gibson is going to make this team and there is zero doubt. Barber is a nothing. He and McKissick can be found on every roster in the NFL and every PS.

I agree AP does not need to be here.

The RBs should be Guice, Gibson, and Love. If you want a fourth, pick one. AP will likely make the team though, even if I disagree with the idea.

 

[deanpet21]

here is the thing we do know JD and barber are not stars

dont have to be stars, they are role players

 

[deanpet21]

Is JD a better receiver or has he just been given more opportunities to be so? From there, is he a better receiver than Gibson because that is JD’s actual competition. Gibson is going to make this team and there is zero doubt. Barber is a nothing. He and McKissick can be found on every roster in the NFL and every PS.

I agree AP does not need to be here.

The RBs should be Guice, Gibson, and Love. If you want a fourth, pick one. AP will likely make the team though, even if I disagree with the idea.

JD was a WR in college and is a perfect 3rd down back for us. Of course Gibson is going to make the team. Gibson is going to be the gadget guy plus get carries. He is 220 pounds. He just as big as Guice. There are going to be four RB;s on the roster. Injures could dictate who will make the team. Well you have my prediction, lets see what happens.

 

[skinsdad62]

dont have to be stars, they are role players

You don’t pass on a possible star for some role players. Come on

hell love can be a younger fresher role player

 

[skinsdad62]

JD was a WR in college and is a perfect 3rd down back for us. Of course Gibson is going to make the team. Gibson is going to be the gadget guy plus get carries. He is 220 pounds. He just as big as Guice. There are going to be four RB;s on the roster. Injures could dictate who will make the team. Well you have my prediction, lets see what happens.

Gibson was a wr in college

 

[deanpet21]

You don’t pass on a possible star for some role players. Come on

hell love can be a younger fresher role player

I hope he is, but im looking at it right now. Bringing in those two guys sent a serious message to Love.

 

[deanpet21]

Gibson was a wr in college

I know. He is going to play alot of roles in our offense.

 

[skinsdad62]

I hope he is, but im looking at it right now. Bringing in those two guys sent a serious message to Love.

bringing in those 2 guys means nothing more then competition for everyone .

 

[skinsdad62]

I know. He is going to play alot of roles in our offense.

yep and possible 3rd down back is one of them for he is far more explosive then either barber or JD

 

[deanpet21]

yep and possible 3rd down back is one of them for he is far more explosive then either barber or JD

Im not doubting Gibson's ability.

 

[skinsdad62]

Bryce Love-Affair - Can the Redskins Running Back Become "The Man" in D.C.?

right here it says he will be healthy for TC . shoot he has had 1 1/2 years to be ready and his explosion dwarfs anything JD or barber have to offer

JD has been a career BU as has barber . i dont know why all of a sudden they are world beaters to you. we have seen their ceilings . they are pedestrian

i would much rather get the explosive love on the field .

and just because one wasnt asked to catch a lot of passes in college doesnt mean he cant . guice being example A and when love did catch the ball he housed it

JD has a paltry 4tds in 5 years of play . we need play makers not avg

 

[Ruzious]

It's all about Guice and Love getting and staying healthy, and finding the right times to slip in AG. We don't want to have to rely on guys like Barber, JD, and AP in a rebuilding year.

 

[skinsdad62]

It's all about Guice and Love getting and staying healthy, and finding the right times to slip in AG. We don't want to have to rely on guys like Barber, JD, and AP in a rebuilding year.

i think AD is insurance . if we are doing the right thing and health works out it should be guice , love and AG carrying the load

 

[skinsdad62]

'Skins Spotlight - J.D. McKissic

some favorable things on JD