Too many RB's

[skinsdad62]

 

[deanpet21]

Right, so how doesn't JD makes this team?

 

[Myles]

Guice, Ap, Gibson, JD, Barber, and Love. Tell me which 4 make the team and why. My opinion Gibson will be the 5th Wr on the team splitting time between Rb and WR. So chose 4 out of the 5.

Why did they draft a RB with their 2nd pick?

 

[Ruzious]

Why did they draft a RB with their 2nd pick?

One thing RR has said several times is how much he values versatility and the ability to play more than 1 position. He can play RB, WR, slot, and return kickoffs. There's also the fact that he's 228 lbs and can run a 4.39 40.

 

[skinsdad62]

Right, so how doesn't JD makes this team?

because gibson can do what he does

a healthy love can push him off the roster a healthy guice too

J.D. McKissic Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com

why do you think this guy is an all star ? he has less the 500 career rushing yds and 4 total TDS going into yr 5

he has a whopping 70 catches for 500 yds going into yr , about 17 a yr

i am sorry but i think gibson can get us 150 yds rushing this yr , catch 17 balls and get about 100 yds rec . and one td this year . that is what JD the great avgs for his career

JD makes the team if there are injuries but if all things are equal i dont think so because i dont see him knocking AD off the roster

 

[deanpet21]

because gibson can do what he does

a healthy love can push him off the roster a healthy guice too

J.D. McKissic Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com

why do you think this guy is an all star ? he has less the 500 career rushing yds and 4 total TDS going into yr 5

he has a whopping 70 catches for 500 yds going into yr , about 17 a yr

i am sorry but i think gibson can get us 150 yds rushing this yr , catch 17 balls and get about 100 yds rec . and one td this year . that is what JD the great avgs for his career

JD makes the team if there are injuries but if all things are equal i dont think so because i dont see him knocking AD off the roster

Make the bet

 

[skinsdad62]

Make the bet

why ? i am not in elementary school . . i stand by my feelings and the evidence i have provided . if i am wrong it wouldnt be the 1st time

there is nothing in JD's career that sceams "must have " on my roster unless there is an injury

 

[skinsdad62]

Redskins’ J.D. McKissic an underrated addition to the running back room

a younger healthier Love sends this guy packing .

 

[deanpet21]

Redskins’ J.D. McKissic an underrated addition to the running back room

a younger healthier Love sends this guy packing .

Love supposed to be healthy right now. JD is going to make the team

 

[skinsdad62]

Love supposed to be healthy right now. JD is going to make the team

Only. If there is an injury

 

[deanpet21]

Only. If there is an injury

So let me get this straight. You got Ap and Guice. Gibson as the 3rd down back and Love as the 4th guy? Do you see this team carry 5 RB's on the active roster?

 

[skinsdad62]

So let me get this straight. You got Ap and Guice. Gibson as the 3rd down back and Love as the 4th guy? Do you see this team carry 5 RB's on the active roster?

No

 

[deanpet21]

No

So that is your 4 making the roster?

 

[skinsdad62]

So that is your 4 making the roster?

yep AD , guice , love gibson

 

[deanpet21]

yep AD , guice , love gibson

What I want is Guice, Gibson, JD, and Barber. What will probably happen is AP, Guice, Gibson and JD.

 

[skinsdad62]

What I want is Guice, Gibson, JD, and Barber. What will probably happen is AP, Guice, Gibson and JD.

I don’t know why you want 2 pedestrian RBS in JD. and Barber over Love

 

[deanpet21]

I don’t know why you want 2 pedestrian RBS in JD. and Barber over Love

b/c we have no idea what we have in Love. Most fans on here excluding me think its going to be a bad year. So why have AP on this team versus younger Rb's? I think we will have a decent year with or without AP.

 

[skinsdad62]

b/c we have no idea what we have in Love. Most fans on here excluding me think its going to be a bad year. So why have AP on this team versus younger Rb's? I think we will have a decent year with or without AP.

barber and JD arent young , love is the better option he is fast explosive , can catch the ball

barber and JD have hit their collective ceilings

 

[deanpet21]

barber and JD arent young , love is the better option he is fast explosive , can catch the ball

barber and JD have hit their collective ceilings

jD 26,Barber 25. JD was a WR in college. Love hasn't taken a NFL snap. If he beats out these guys it would be b/c of his draft status(4th round).

 

[skinsdad62]

jD 26,Barber 25. JD was a WR in college. Love hasn't taken a NFL snap. If he beats out these guys it would be b/c of his draft status(4th round).

if he beats them out its because he is better . RR didnt draft him