Tony Gwynn vs Rod Carew

[DrewScott]

From 1975 to current 2025 Gwynn is one of my starters in the outfield, along with Bonds and Griffey, JR.

ah what the hell, here's the whole line up

C- Piazza
1b- Pujols
2b-Altuve
ss- Arod
3b-Schmidt
Bonds
Griffey
Gwynn

DH-Judge

 

[UK Cowboy]

From 1975 to current 2025 Gwynn is one of my starters in the outfield, along with Bonds and Griffey, JR.

ah what the hell, here's the whole line up

C- Piazza
1b- Pujols
2b-Altuve
ss- Arod
3b-Schmidt
Bonds
Griffey
Gwynn

DH-Judge

That's a nice group. I would go Bench and Pudge Rodriguez at C, just because their defense was so far superior to Piazza, if you want the stick its Piazza. Could make a case for ManRam at DH but Judge is great. Joe Morgan definitely gets the nod at 2B for me.

 

[navamind]

From 1975 to current 2025 Gwynn is one of my starters in the outfield, along with Bonds and Griffey, JR.

ah what the hell, here's the whole line up

C- Piazza
1b- Pujols
2b-Altuve
ss- Arod
3b-Schmidt
Bonds
Griffey
Gwynn

DH-Judge

Sounds about right, though unless Mookie falls off a cliff he'll most likely finish with the better career than Gwynn. I would have said Robinson, Kaline or Clemente but those guys' careers wrapped up around/before your time frame.