The All Time Cowboy Team

[jarntt]

Fitzgerald over Frederick, Eric Williams over Tyron Smith, Benny Barnes over Deon, Ware over Lee, Pearson over Dez

I can't put Frederick on mine because it's too early but I think he easily ends up #1. I guess I go Fitz I guess. I agree on Williams. Really think he'd be one of the best ever if he didn't get hurt. Deion on the list for sure. Can't put ware at LB over Lee. If you want to put Ware on you need to put him over a DE. I usually go longevity on these lists, but Dez has put up such big numbers it's hard to leave him off. I'll put both and sit my 2nd RB...

 

[Manster7588]

The amazing thing is almost all difference of opinions here can make sense. Replacing great players with great players.

 

[jarntt]

The amazing thing is almost all difference of opinions here can make sense. Replacing great players with great players.

No. Only MY decision counts!!!

 

[jarntt]

HaHa

 

[Manster7588]

No. Only MY decision counts!!!

Repeating what your wife tells you holds no water here.

 

[PDay8810]

Repeating what your wife tells you holds no water here.

so true

I just don't think neither Williams or Wright coulda been as good at LT. Maybe Ralph Neely or Tuenni.

Dave Manders was a good center. Stepnoski was a favorite but short lived. Fits and Rafferty both were good centers. No wrong responses

 

[ArlingtonCowboys100]

Erik Williams would have made this list if not for the car wreck. He was headed for the HOF up until that point. Was not the same player after that although he was still above average.

 

[CarlSr]

Erik Williams would have made this list if not for the car wreck. He was headed for the HOF up until that point.

Yeah, maybe I'm an E. Williams ball-washer, but I see it the same way. When a guy kicks so much ass, rivals mention him in their HoF speeches, I take notice. Before the accident, he was a beast.

I don't know that I differ too much with the list. It does feel like Ware should be there, but at the same time, something has always bothered me about the Romo years. It's always been all on Romo when the team hasn't gotten it done. Guys like Witten and Ware get passess from most. Why? If they're really great, why do they get a pass? I feel like Witten has done enough to earn a spot. Ware? I can respect the opinion, but I don't respect when it's not even up for debate. Not saying anyone here is doing that, but I've encountered it before. I could go either way with him.

 

[tomodach10]

T-Eric williams, Wright, og-Newton,nye,c-stepnoski, qb-Roger, rb, Emmitt, fb- garrison, recievers-Irving,Dez, te-witten, lbs-Jordan,ware,howley,dt-white,Lilly, db-Sandes, Renfro, saftey, Adderly, woody, kicker-fitch.de-haley, martin.

 

[cowboycolors]

Staubach over Aikman I agree both were special but Roger was the better of the 2 IMHO
You could put Allen anywhere on that line except center and make an argument he fits there that's how good he was
good list

 

[tomodach10]

I forgot about Allen. Thanks!!!

 

[TheStarOne]

I'm going to cheat here...Put some, in not their natural positions.

Rayfield Wright,Erik Williams ...OT
Nate Newton Larry Allen ...Guards
Mark Stepnoski....Center

Jason Witten, Jay Novacek..TWO TEs
Michael Irvin, Dez Bryant.... WRs
Daryl Johnston...FB
EMMITT SMITH...RB

Demarcus Ware, Charles Haley ...DEs
Randy White,Bob Lilly..DTs
Ken Norton Jr. MLB, Sean Lee, Chuck Howley... LBs
Darren Woodson, James Washington ...FS
Deion Sanders,Mel Renfro....CBs
Dan Bailey .Kicker

Coach Jimmy Johnson


Oh yeah, quarterback .......Troy Aikman

 

[tomodach10]

I can't put Frederick on mine because it's too early but I think he easily ends up #1. I guess I go Fitz I guess. I agree on Williams. Really think he'd be one of the best ever if he didn't get hurt. Deion on the list for sure. Can't put ware at LB over Lee. If you want to put Ware on you need to put him over a DE. I usually go longevity on these lists, but Dez has put up such big numbers it's hard to leave him off. I'll put both and sit my 2nd RB...

Ware is a linebacker in 4/3 no way is Sean Lee an all time cowboy yet! He can't stay healthy.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Ware is a linebacker in 4/3 no way is Sean Lee an all time cowboy yet! He can't stay healthy.

Lee over LRJ? I think not....

 

[jarntt]

Ware is a linebacker in 4/3 no way is Sean Lee an all time cowboy yet! He can't stay healthy.

No. Ware is not a LB in a 4-3

 

[tomodach10]

No. Ware is not a LB in a 4-3

Yes he is!!

 

[ROMOTOOWENS]

Ware exact size as MCClain . He would have been fine.

 

[jarntt]

Yes he is!!

Ware is a DE in a 4-3. He is a OLB in a 3-4.

 

[jarntt]

Ware exact size as MCClain . He would have been fine.

Size is only a piece of the puzzle. You want Ware covering more than just the needed screen pickup he has done? You want him chasing plays and moving in space or do you want him at the point of attack? Could he do it? Probably, but there is no way that would be his best fit IMO

 

[ROMOTOOWENS]

Size is only a piece of the puzzle. You want Ware covering more than just the needed screen pickup he has done? You want him chasing plays and moving in space or do you want him at the point of attack? Could he do it? Probably, but there is no way that would be his best fit IMO

No not his best fit, but Haley, Martin and Ware all deserve to be on the team