The 8-8-8 NFL Draft QF3 : 500 vs Shane

[Nosferatu]

500

OFFENSE
QB - Aaron Rodgers - Packers - 2008
RB - Chris Johnson - Titans - 2008
FB - John Williams - Seahawks - 1988
WR - Cris Carter - Vikings - 1988
WR - Michael Irvin - Cowboys - 1988
WR - Tommy McDonald - Eagles - 1968
TE - Bob Trumpy - Bengals - 1968
LT - Art Shell - Raiders - 1968
LG - Brian Waters - Chiefs - 2008
C - Bart Oates - Giants - 1988
RG - Gene Hickerson - Browns - 1968
RT - Bob Brown - Eagles - 1968

DEFENSE
DE - John Abraham - Falcons - 2008
DT - Alex Karras - Lions - 1968
DT - Joe Klecko - Jets - 1988
DE - Jason Taylor - Dolphins - 2008
LB - Mike Stratton - Bills - 1968
MLB - Ray Lewis - Ravens - 2008
LB - Mike Curtis - Colts - 1968
CB - Darrell Green - Redskins - 1988
CB - Asante Samuel - Patriots - 2008
NCB - Charles Tillman - Bears - 2008
SS - Dennis Smith - Broncos - 1988
FS - Ronnie Lott - 49ers - 1988

VS

SHANE

OFFENSE
QB - Joe Montana - 49ers - 1988
HB - Shaun Alexander - Seahawks - 2008
FB - Tom Rathman - 49ers - 1988
WR - Marvin Harrison - Colts - 2008
WR - Torry Holt - Rams - 2008
WR - "Bullet" Bob Hayes - Cowboys - 1968
TE - Greg Olsen - Panthers - 2008
LT - Joe Jacoby - Redskins - 1988
LG - Tom Mack - Rams - 1968
C - Jon Morris - Patriots - 1968
RG - Russ Grimm - Redskins - 1988
RT - Willie Anderson - Bengals - 2008

DEFENSE
DE - Carl Eller - Vikings - 1968
DT - Jerome Brown - Eagles - 1988
DT - Kevin Williams - Vikings - 2008
DE - Robert Mathis - Colts - 2008
OLB - Dave Robinson - Packers - 1968
MLB - Ray Nitschke - Packers - 1968
OLB - Chuck Howley - Cowboys - 1968
CB - Rod Woodson - Steelers - 1988
CB - Albert Lewis - Chiefs - 1988
NCB - Dick LeBeau - Lions - 1968
SS - Ed Reed - Ravens - 2008
FS - Deron Cherry - Chiefs - 1988

 

[Nosferatu]

500 - 6
SHANE - 1

VOTED - UK, Mookie, Femur, Sushi,

Race to Six

 

[UK Cowboy]

500

 

[Mookie]

Shane in a squeaker. Love both offenses and secondaries

 

[CitySushi]

I think it's a close matchup but I got 500.

 

[femurov]

500

 

[tducey]

500

 

[Ritzarmy]

500

 

[Shanemansj13]

I thought 500 had one of the best teams. Just too close for me not to take my team, both teams have their advantages.

Overall I have the better defense (secondary and LB's).
D-line is wash pretty much.
O-line his is better.
Weapons wise and offensive scheme I think he has the advantage but it's slight. An somewhat mobile ARodg does help him but not if he is injured or bitching at the HC bc of the playcalling

 

[MilkSpiller22]

shane

 

[blstoker]

Shane

 

[Hall]

So close, whoever has the ball last probably wins. Teams are built similarly as well. I like 500 slightly in the trenches so going with him.

 

[Pack 500]

500

 

[Pack 500]

I thought 500 had one of the best teams. Just too close for me not to take my team, both teams have their advantages.

Overall I have the better defense (secondary and LB's).
D-line is wash pretty much.
O-line his is better.
Weapons wise and offensive scheme I think he has the advantage but it's slight. An somewhat mobile ARodg does help him but not if he is injured or bitching at the HC bc of the playcalling

Since when are players in our drafts playing hurt lol. And you’re talking about the last year with McCarthy instead of the other 10?

 

[Nosferatu]

I thought when I posted this game it might be the best of the draft s far, this and the UK v Sushi game...


Great job @Pack 500

 

[Shanemansj13]

Since when are players in our drafts playing hurt lol. And you’re talking about the last year with McCarthy instead of the other 10?

We should have drafted backup QB's for this reason. Him and McCarthy had friction in the past too

 

[Nosferatu]

Since when are players in our drafts playing hurt lol. And you’re talking about the last year with McCarthy instead of the other 10?

It's a loophole!!

 

[Shanemansj13]

It's a loophole!!

A ton of loopholes...too bad I can't use any of them

 

[Pack 500]

We should have drafted backup QB's for this reason. Him and McCarthy had friction in the past too

Greg Olsen is “injury prone” by that standard so I guess we should’ve drafted backup tight ends too? And is McCarthy my coach? Not that any “friction” mattered before this year. I’m confused lol.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Greg Olsen is “injury prone” by that standard so I guess we should’ve drafted backup tight ends too? And is McCarthy my coach? Not that any “friction” mattered before this year. I’m confused lol.

I'm not so sure a TE is as important as a QB but I was actually just joking around from the start LOL no worries, I would have stuck up for Baker too