some yes or no TRADE advice requested

[The Foot]

Hey guys I need some opinions here on atrade that has been proposed.

What side would you like to receive in a deal?

Side A gets:

Marshawn Lynch
Tony Romo
Jason Witten
Andre Williams Rb NYG

Side B gets:
Russel Wilson
Tyler Eifert
Khalil Mack
thrid round pick (only lower lever rookies avail in draft)

Which side would you like to take home?

 

[TREFF]

This season team A by a landslide. For the long term? Team B although they probably should have a higher rounds pick to "even it out". Obviously a deal with the future in mind.

 

[tlance]

Yes.

 

[tlance]

I agree with Treff on all points. I think this is a great time to buy low on Lynch. Even if he retires, the pieces that side A get in return should be enough to offset the long term cost of what side B is getting.

Even if side A lacks a franchise QB aside from Wilson, I would make this deal if I were on that side.

 

[TKOSpikes]

If I had A I wouldn't even think about it. There is no for sure with Eiffert, and Mack is a LB and you know how I feel about that Foot. So to get RW, I'm not giving up Romo and Lynch.

 

[The Foot]

thanks guys any other heavy hitters on here want to voice their opinion on this deal. You know you can never get enough reassurance when it comes to trades!

 

[Bandit]

Side A in a landslide. You are getting a better quarterback, a better tight end, and basically Marshawn Lynch for a third round pick. This is like an 85/15 trade for side A.

 

[The Foot]

Canes thanks for your valued input as well. I am very happy to hear you and the rest of the guys all seem pretty certain this is a slam dunk. I am the one getting side A if you haven't guessed and even though I think the guys I gave up will be pretty good to great in the near future I think side A is more the "the bird in the hand" side plus I really like Andres Williams. He is the main reason I did it.

Anyone else who feels like chiming in please do.

 

[SteelersPride]

Side a no hesitation