MBBRL SCORING CHANGE THREAD

[MilkSpiller22]

CURRENT SCORING:

Scoring Group	Scoring Category	Points
Hitting	At Bats (AB)	-0.25
Hitting	Caught Stealing (CS)	-1
Hitting	Grounded Into Double Plays (GIDP)	-1.5
Hitting	Hit By Pitches (HBP)	0.75
Hitting	Hits (H)	1.25
Hitting	Home Runs (HR)	2
Hitting	Runs Batted In (RBI)	1
Hitting	Runs Scored (R)	1
Hitting	Stolen Bases (SB)	1.5
Hitting	Strikeouts (SO)	-0.75
Hitting	Walks (BB)	1
Hitting	Extra Base Hits (XBH)	2
Pitching	Blown Saves (BS)	-3
Pitching	Earned Runs Allowed (ER)	-0.5
Pitching	Hits Allowed (H)	-1
Pitching	Holds (HLD)	6
Pitching	Inherited Runners (IR)	-0.75
Pitching	Inherited Runners Stranded (IRS)	1.25
Pitching	Innings Pitched (IP)	2
Pitching	Losses (L)	-2.5
Pitching	Quality Starts (QS)	5
Pitching	Runs Allowed (R)	-1
Pitching	Saves (SV)	7
Pitching	Strikeouts Pitched (K)	1
Pitching	Walks Allowed (BB)	-1.25
Pitching	Wins (W)	5

 

[MilkSpiller22]

@catman , @Yellow Fuzzies ,@TKOSpikes , @Chef99 , @bksballer89 , @molsaniceman , @obxyankeefan , @Shanemansj13 , @Robotech ,@broncosmitty , @jwolt92 , @Stakesarehigh


any suggestions for scoring changes??

 

[bksballer89]

Holds down to 4 or 5 points. Cant be worth more than a QS or W

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Holds down to 4 or 5 points. Cant be worth more than a QS or W

i would like to do a full on changing for all Holds, WINS, QS, SAVES... also would like to do a differential between wins by a starter and wins by a reliever...

 

[MilkSpiller22]

maybe
5- QS
5- Starter win
2- Relief win
4- Holds
5- Saves

 

[Shanemansj13]

SO's from .75 to .50 (I get they are bad outs but still drastic)
Hold from 6 to 5 or bump up saves one point
If Saves are 8, blown saves should be half or 4 IMO

Homeruns same as extra base hits?
Why are ab's negative again?

 

[Shanemansj13]

maybe
5- QS
5- Starter win
2- Relief win
4- Holds
5- Saves

I think there should be two points between holds and saves. More pressure for a save imo

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I think there should be two points between holds and saves. More pressure for a save imo

so 3 for Holds or 6 for saves??

 

[Shanemansj13]

so 3 for Holds or 6 for saves??

Fine with 6 for saves and 4 for holds.

 

[Robotech]

i would like to do a full on changing for all Holds, WINS, QS, SAVES... also would like to do a differential between wins by a starter and wins by a reliever...

Maybe 5 points for a starter win and 3 points for a reliever win?? I do wonder if we should just take wins and losses out entirely because a pitcher doesn't control whether he gets run support. Maybe take out wins and losses while making a quality start worth 8 points. And maybe there should be bonus points for completing 7, 8, and 9 innings.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

SO's from .75 to .50 (I get they are bad outs but still drastic)
Hold from 6 to 5 or bump up saves one point
If Saves are 8, blown saves should be half or 4 IMO

Homeruns same as extra base hits?
Why are ab's negative again?

ABs are not really negative... it is just an easier way to penalize for outs...

 

[Robotech]

I think that the strikeout penalty is too much. Maybe make it minus 0.25 or 0.50 points instead of minus 0.75. It nearly negates a run or RBI. I acquired a high contact guy in Jung Hoo Lee, so this doesn't benefit me in the short term, but I think it's better in the long term to not penalize strikeouts this much.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Maybe 5 points for a starter win and 3 points for a reliever win?? I do wonder if we should just take wins and losses out entirely because a pitcher doesn't control whether he gets run support. Maybe take out wins and losses while making a quality start worth 8 points. And maybe there should be bonus points for completing 7, 8, and 9 innings.

i love different thinking... but i dont think i am ready yet in fantasy theoretics to take away the win category....

 

[Robotech]

i love different thinking... but i dont think i am ready yet in fantasy theoretics to take away the win category....

Understood. I'm in favor of just keeping the same points for a starter win and a reliever win. A reliever isn't going to get a lot of wins and I think it's fine to have lucky things like that happen. Starters get a bunch of points from other stat categories.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I think that the strikeout penalty is too much. Maybe make it minus 0.25 or 0.50 points instead of minus 0.75. It nearly negates a run or RBI. I acquired a high contact guy in Jung Hoo Lee, so this doesn't benefit me in the short term, but I think it's better in the long term to not penalize strikeouts this much.

i have always wondered about this when it comes to fantasy sports... why do we immortalize the strike out skill for pitchers, but ignore the contact hitter sklill...

i would say the same thing when it comes to HR for hitters, and HR for pitchers... but that is a little different, as it is already a factor in scoring... WHIP, and ERA...

 

[MilkSpiller22]

SO's from .75 to .50 (I get they are bad outs but still drastic)
Hold from 6 to 5 or bump up saves one point
If Saves are 8, blown saves should be half or 4 IMO

Homeruns same as extra base hits?
Why are ab's negative again?

as to HRs being the same as XBH... thats not true... in fact HRs should be only 1 and not 2...

but remember if you get a HR that is ALSO an XBH... so you get points for both...

might just be easier and cleaner to just use Total bases instead of Hits, HRS, and XBH... maybe a .5 bonus for HRs...

i do remember my logic when i used XBH instead of TB... but ruined it when i designated 2 points for HR instead of 1...

 

[Stakesarehigh]

Holds down to 4 or 5 points. Cant be worth more than a QS or W

Eliminate the runners inherited portion also.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Eliminate the runners inherited portion also.

can i ask why?? that is one of the milkian scorings that i actually like...

 

[Stakesarehigh]

can i ask why?? that is one of the milkian scorings that i actually like...

Or maybe give starters some more swag idk. It's wild seeing starters go 5 and 2/3 give up 1 run and score 8 pts or something. Then a reliever comes in for a one innig hold and gets 11.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Or maybe give starters some more swag idk. It's wild seeing starters go 5 and 2/3 give up 1 run and score 8 pts or something. Then a reliever comes in for a one innig hold and gets 11.

the IRS is not the reason for that... its the Wins/holds/saves that does that... the most a pitcher can receive in IRS is 1.5...