Luck vs Griffin

[Mondio]

not really. a brace will protect you in early stages so you don't do something small like twist or because of proprioceptive loss, lose our balance and put stress on the knee that will re-injure the tissues. That's it.

If the knee is still that weak, so he won't twist on some bad turf and tear it. It's not going to do anything when he's in a pile of 300+ pounders putting a hit on him or running down field and goes to make a cut. Like I said, a matter of time.

 

[BUD]

Andrew Luck would be my pick. I think he will do better and last longer in the NFL than Griffin.

 

[BOTSLAYER]

until a running QB can prove they can be effective long term I am taking Luck. Kap, Wilson, RG3 and maybe Cam might prove this. And then I will take Kap.

 

[RoboticDreams]

until a running QB can prove they can be effective long term I am taking Luck. Kap, Wilson, RG3 and maybe Cam might prove this. And then I will take Kap.

I finally agree with you on something.

 

[Arizona_Sting]

Luck is the better QB. Love RG3 but I think Luck's upside is tremendous.

 

[Jims_Doors]

It's Luck and it's not that close. He's the much better pure passer and doesn't have the running game (referring to RB) that Griffin has.

 

[mcro_rave_2001]

Can't go wrong with either but i'm taking Luck because of RG3's injury issues.

 

[JDM]

until a running QB can prove they can be effective long term I am taking Luck. Kap, Wilson, RG3 and maybe Cam might prove this. And then I will take Kap.

Griffin is a better passer than luck. He does not need to run. If he has a worse career it is because Shanahan ruined him by putting him in harms way with no need to. He is already by far the best passer among young guys, and given a couple years, he will likely be the best passer in the NFL.

 

[Jims_Doors]

^^^^^

 

[RobBase]

The next run-first/scrambling QB to win a SB will be the first one. Luck is everything you want in a prototypical NFL QB. RG3 is Mike Vick without the dog fights.

 

[Lonewate44]

The next run-first/scrambling QB to win a SB will be the first one. Luck is everything you want in a prototypical NFL QB. RG3 is Mike Vick without the dog fights.

RG3 is Mike Vick less the dog fights....Really?? No way...He is a Much better passer, and Way more accurate then Vick ever thought of being...RGII can...unlike Mike ya know...actually read a defense....and RGII can throw the ball Very good, I dont believe he is a run first guy....I believe he look sot make the pass first...becasue he is a good accurate thrower!!!

 

[Mondio]

I think RGIII is more of a qb than Vick. I think he understands the game better already for one.

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

"The only people who think Griffin is better than Luck are Redskin fans, blacks, or just plain stupid."

 

[HuskerCradle2Grave]

I'd take Luck even if RGIII had never been injured in his life. Luck might already be the best QB in the NFL at the tender age of 23 (24 in a couple of days).

I'll take CK over both those chumps...

 

[SoCalWizFan]

"The only people who think Griffin is better than Luck are Redskin fans, blacks, or just plain stupid."

Thanks for providing the redneck perspective on this one. What time is your Klan meeting tonight?

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

Thanks for providing the redneck perspective on this one. What time is your Klan meeting tonight?

How is my quote racist?

 

[Sportsguy9695]

Im a big fan of RGIII. But he is injury prone with all the scrambling he does. Luck is an awful good pockets passer but im more of a fan of a QB that can scramble

 

[NinerSickness]

Im a big fan of RGIII. But he is injury prone with all the scrambling he does. Luck is an awful good pockets passer but im more of a fan of a QB that can scramble

Are you joking? Luck is a great scrambler. He has one of the best size / speed combinations of any starting QB in the league.

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

Im a big fan of RGIII. But he is injury prone with all the scrambling he does. Luck is an awful good pockets passer but im more of a fan of a QB that can scramble

NFL Videos - Game Highlights

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

Im a big fan of RGIII. But he is injury prone with all the scrambling he does. Luck is an awful good pockets passer but im more of a fan of a QB that can scramble

NFL Videos - Game Highlights