Luck vs Griffin

[Am I Blue Through it All?]

We all gush over Luck around here. His potential. His devotion to the game. His humility and "aw shucks" persona. He is clearly a 15 year vet at "football speak."

But his potential is as yet, unactualized. Am I hoping he will be a great as we expect? Sure. But only time will tell.

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

Are you trying to act stupid or does it come naturally? Oh well - you are probably just some uninformed 13 yr old - good luck pal.

Comes to no surprise that only Redskin fans take offense to my quote. Griffin has a chance to be a good QB, be happy with that. You guys haven't had a good QB since Joe Theismann, and to a lesser extent, Mark Rypien. But RG3 will never, I mean never be in Luck's league.

 

[Breaker99]

Griffin over every young QB and no one else is legitimately close.

This again, stop embarrassing yourself.


There is definitely players who are close. Wilson, Kaepernick easily approach RGIII's level if not surpass it. And I would take Luck over RGIII anyway.

 

[SoCalWizFan]

Comes to no surprise that only Redskin fans take offense to my quote. Griffin has a chance to be a good QB, be happy with that. You guys haven't had a good QB since Joe Theismann, and to a lesser extent, Mark Rypien. But RG3 will never, I mean never be in Luck's league.

Wrong. You missed the part where I stated that I also liked & respected Luck & Wilson. Why does liking one of these guys have to be accompanied by disliking the other two? The reality of the situation is that none of us know how these guys will be doing in 4-5 years.

Anyhow - I don't take exception to your statement about Redskins fans. I take exception to the fact that you stated that the only other people who like RG3 are either black or stupid which is 100% incorrect. I also really took exception to your whole rant about chicken & watermelon. Who are you - Sergio Garcia? If you don't see the stupidity of your comments then you must be a big time redneck.

BTW - what does "comes to no surprise" mean? It is "comes as no surprise". Idiot.

 

[SoCalWizFan]

This again, stop embarrassing yourself.


There is definitely players who are close. Wilson, Kaepernick easily approach RGIII's level if not surpass it. And I would take Luck over RGIII anyway.

Hard to tell - need more time to evaluate all of them. Keapernick vs. RG3 is also hard to evaluate since Kaepernick is surrounded by more talent especially on the O-line. Anyhow - not ragging on him in any way - I like him & your team for the most part (except when the coach acts like an idiot).

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

Wrong. You missed the part where I stated that I also liked & respected Luck & Wilson. Why does liking one of these guys have to be accompanied by disliking the other two? The reality of the situation is that none of us know how these guys will be doing in 4-5 years.

Anyhow - I don't take exception to your statement about Redskins fans. I take exception to the fact that you stated that the only other people who like RG3 are either black or stupid which is 100% incorrect. I also really took exception to your whole rant about chicken & watermelon. Who are you - Sergio Garcia? If you don't see the stupidity of your comments then you must be a big time redneck.

BTW - what does "comes to no surprise" mean? It is "comes as no surprise". Idiot.

Let's be honest here, you take offense only because you feel as though my quote degrades your QB. To play 2nd fiddle to Andrew Luck isn't necessarily a bad thing. Cheer up!

 

[JDM]

This again, stop embarrassing yourself.


There is definitely players who are close. Wilson, Kaepernick easily approach RGIII's level if not surpass it. And I would take Luck over RGIII anyway.

No. They aren't close.

 

[Breaker99]

Hard to tell - need more time to evaluate all of them. Keapernick vs. RG3 is also hard to evaluate since Kaepernick is surrounded by more talent especially on the O-line. Anyhow - not ragging on him in any way - I like him & your team for the most part (except when the coach acts like an idiot).

I can't argue that Kaepernick is not at an advantage because of our offensive line. Thats a valid point worth considering. But his TD to INT ration and efficiency is still off the hook for a guy with 12 NFL starts.

And in regards to harbaugh, you just need to embrace his antics... its all part of the plan.

 

[Breaker99]

No. They aren't close.

Dude, you are the only one saying that, what does that tell you?


(let me guess, that you are the only one who is right?)

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I like luck the best... does anyone find it funny that luck has a horse shoe on his helmet??

 

[JDM]

Dude, you are the only one saying that, what does that tell you?


(let me guess, that you are the only one who is right?)

I'm not the only one saying he is the clear best.

 

[SoCalWizFan]

I can't argue that Kaepernick is not at an advantage because of our offensive line. Thats a valid point worth considering. But his TD to INT ration and efficiency is still off the hook for a guy with 12 NFL starts.

And in regards to harbaugh, you just need to embrace his antics... its all part of the plan.

You know how that works - love the guy if he is your coach & probably hate him (at least somewhat) if he is not - especially if you root for a rival like Seattle.

Also - RG3 has a very, very good TD to INT ratio (except for the 1st half of Monday nt). We will see how it works out for the rest of the year. They are both very good QBs. I would not mind having either.

 

[SoCalWizFan]

Let's be honest here, you take offense only because you feel as though my quote degrades your QB. To play 2nd fiddle to Andrew Luck isn't necessarily a bad thing. Cheer up!

Nope - don't care if you like the guy or the Redskins. Why should I care about the opinion of a moron? I was just calling you out since you didn't have to act like a racist clown in the process (with your stupid chicken remark ala Sergio Garcia).

Oh well - I guess you need at least half a brain to appreciate guys from other teams & not be a complete homer.

 

[bigred472]

I liked RG in college; however believe that Luck's skill set fits the pro game better and he will be around for a very long time. I would have drafted Luck first in spite of how well Griffin played in college.

^^^^^^^
THIS

 

[raptorlife4]

If RG3 ever gets to 100% again he is a top 3 qb in the NFL

 

[BoP]

Luck by far.

 

[Kid Vicarious]

If RG3 ever gets to 100% again he is a top 3 qb in the NFL

That's a big IF. I see RG3 having a lot of missed games in his future.

 

[BoP]

Even if he's healthy, he's not even close.

 

[Steelboy84]

Still RGIII

 

[Doublejive]

LOL RG3 is the 15 to 20 year old male range,they love him but RG3 is one big hit away from being a nobody in the NFL,you cannot come back after three knee surgery's imo.

Just watch and see,been telling people since last year.