Knee-Jerk: Name your top 10 PG's of all time, let's hash out the stats/accomplishments later

[Mr. Friscus]

"Point Guard" can be a vague position, as many guys who clearly aren't PG's can take on the position (Lebron)

But, I'm going to make a list of all likely concievable options... and I want you to rank them top 10, and include others that I leave off: Then, in the nest post, I'll give my list.

Elite Point guards:
- Magic Johnson
- John Stockton
- Chris Paul
- Steph Curry
- Oscar Robertson
- Isaiah Thomas
- Steve Nash
- Jason Kidd
- Russ Westbrook
- Bob Cousy
- Walt Frazier
- Kyrie Irving
- Allen Iverson
- Tim Hardaway
- Gary Payton
- Nate Archibald
- Tony Parker
- Add your own

 

[Mr. Friscus]

My top 10:
1. Magic Johnoson
2. Steph Curry
3. Oscar Robertson
4. John Stockton
5. Steve Nash
6. Bob Cousy
7: Isaiah Thomas
8. Chris Paul
9. Jason Kidd
10. Gary Payton

 

[DJ Fieri]

This again? Like this hasn't been done before on here.....SMH.

PS: Next up, re-hashing the TB12 vs Manning debate. LOL.

 

[tlance]

This again? Like this hasn't been done before on here.....SMH.

PS: Next up, re-hashing the TB12 vs Manning debate. LOL.

Guy has been here since February.

And I don’t think anything like this has come up in a few years.

 

[tlance]

Here is my top 10:

Magic
Curry
Oscar Robertson
Chris Paul
John Stockton
Steve Nash
Isaiah Thomas
Jason Kidd
Gary Payton
Allen Iverson

Top 3 are a cut above everyone else by a good bit IMO.

Not much separating 4-10. All great players with a flaw of some sort in their overall resumes holding them back from the upper tiers.

 

[DJ Fieri]

Guy has been here since February.

And I don’t think anything like this has come up in a few years.

Been here since Feb under his most recent account. He has been here before, pretty sure of it.

 

[tlance]

"Point Guard" can be a vague position, as many guys who clearly aren't PG's can take on the position (Lebron)

But, I'm going to make a list of all likely concievable options... and I want you to rank them top 10, and include others that I leave off: Then, in the nest post, I'll give my list.

Elite Point guards:
- Magic Johnson
- John Stockton
- Chris Paul
- Steph Curry
- Oscar Robertson
- Isaiah Thomas
- Steve Nash
- Jason Kidd
- Russ Westbrook
- Bob Cousy
- Walt Frazier
- Kyrie Irving
- Allen Iverson
- Tim Hardaway
- Gary Payton
- Nate Archibald
- Tony Parker
- Add your own

James Harden needs to be on the list of consideration.

He is not top 10 IMO, but would rank him clearly above a few on here

 

[tlance]

Been here since Feb under his most recent account. He has been here before, pretty sure of it.

Stop with that man.

You accuse every new person of being an alt. That is a tired act.

 

[DJ Fieri]

Stop with that man.

You accuse every new person of being an alt. That is a tired act.

Not every, but a lot....not Xeliou66 or a few others that have popped up in the last few years....

But, guys that come in here trolling or rehashing old and tired topics? Yeah, because tHoop isn't exactly being marketed and advertised in a lot of different ways to attract new users. And both this guy and the MAGA cat have most likely been here before. I could be wrong but don't think I am.

PS: Having said all that, I will admit I am skeptical of a lot of new users....but not every new user.

 

[DJ Fieri]

Guns n Guitars is still here, I just can't figure out which account he is in here under.

 

[DJ Fieri]

But, to be part of the "topical" discussion:

1-Magic
2-The Big O
3-CP3
4-Steph
5-Stockton
6-Bad Boys Thomas
7-Jason Kidd
8-Payton
9-Nash
10-AI (more of a combo guard, but will say PG for this discussion)

Honorable mention: Harden, Irving, Cousy, Archibald, Frazier.

 

[Used 2 B Hu]

Nobody mention Muggsy Bogues or Spud Webb yet? Not only were they great players in smaller bodies, but they both have all-time great basketball names

 

[shopson67]

James Harden needs to be on the list of consideration.

He is not top 10 IMO, but would rank him clearly above a few on here

I question Curry's inclusion. He's topped 8 apg once. He's a SG imo.

 

[tlance]

I question Curry's inclusion. He's topped 8 apg once. He's a SG imo.

He is a combo guard.

More of a point than AI IMO.

The thing with Curry is he doesn’t dominate the ball at all. He gives it up and runs off screens a lot.

 

[eaglesnut]

10:
Jerry West
Magic Johnson
John Stockton
Steve Nash
Oscar Robertson
Chris Paul
Stef Curry
Allen Iverson
Luka Doncic
Isaiah Thomas

HM:
Gary Payton
Jason Kidd
Bob Cousy

 

[Mr. Friscus]

Been here since Feb under his most recent account. He has been here before, pretty sure of it.

Sorry, I came from usmessageboard.com because their sports page was lame and didn’t have much traffic.

Odd that you’re so invested in trying to sniff someone out… I’d get a hobby dude

 

[DJ Fieri]

Just joined, might be a spot to go all flamethrower at.

 

[rmilia1]

Magic
Steph
Big O
Isaiah
West
CP3
Nash
Stockton
JKidd
Russ

 

[Used 2 B Hu]

Sorry, I came from usmessageboard.com because their sports page was lame and didn’t have much traffic.

Odd that you’re so invested in trying to sniff someone out… I’d get a hobby dude

Nah, but you post in that real sly voice, like you know everybody and have been here before!

 

[logic]

"Point Guard" can be a vague position, as many guys who clearly aren't PG's can take on the position (Lebron)

But, I'm going to make a list of all likely concievable options... and I want you to rank them top 10, and include others that I leave off: Then, in the nest post, I'll give my list.

Elite Point guards:
- Magic Johnson
- John Stockton
- Chris Paul
- Steph Curry
- Oscar Robertson
- Isaiah Thomas
- Steve Nash
- Jason Kidd
- Russ Westbrook
- Bob Cousy
- Walt Frazier
- Kyrie Irving
- Allen Iverson
- Tim Hardaway
- Gary Payton
- Nate Archibald
- Tony Parker
- Add your own

I guessing you meant Isiah Thomas not Isaiah Thomas. It's a small difference, but kind of a big difference.