cezero
Goldmember
Justin Smoak's dWAR since coming to Seattle:
2010: -0.4
2011: -0.9
2012: -0.8
2013: -1.5
2014: -0.5
He is hitting .225 with a .299 OBP. Smoak is in the bottom 5 of starting 1Bs in MLB. The saddest part is that the Mariners OF, SS and DH positions have arguably been worse and deserve priority over replacing Smoak.
yep
massive deficiencies all around offensively. the myth of smoak's amazing defense is baffling from otherwise knowledgeable fans like NW.
it's not just a couple of pieces, it's lots.
some of the kids may just need more MLB at bats, but there's no way that the most of the likes of smoak, ackley, miller, and even seager shouldn't be seen as upgradable by a front office hoping to build a team that can contend perennially.
Last edited by a moderator: