SLY
Mr. Knowitall
I say absolutely not to any current players.
The only exception I could make is if we did a representation of the top scorer in each franchise's history and the all-time leading scorer is a current player.
I'd do something like the Cup in the middle and the team logos surrounding it. Maybe superimpose the Kings logo over the base of the Cup for this season. Update each season (as needed) with the Cup winner.
I like the Cup idea with the current winners on it if someone has the skills to do so.