Has Andy Reid made the top 10 of all-time NFL head coaches?

[saturdaysarebetter]

Pictured are the top 10 NFL head coaches as chosen for the NFL's 100th Anniversary team. Has Andy Reid now made the top 10 of all-time NFL head coaches?

If you believe yes, who does he replace?

 

[Clayton]

Belichick's reputation has kinda gone to crap relative to where it was

 

[Yankee Traveler]

Pictured are the top 10 NFL head coaches as chosen for the NFL's 100th Anniversary team. Has Andy Reid now made the top 10 of all-time NFL head coaches?

If you believe yes, who does he replace?

View attachment 389398

No.

Hall of very good. That ass whooping with no second half adjustments...?
That takes him out of top 10 at least.

 

[Yankee Traveler]

Belichick's reputation has kinda gone to crap relative to where it was

 

[Xeliou66]

Yes I think Andy Reid is top 10 - 3 Super Bowl wins, 6 Super Bowl appearances, and a lot of success in both KC and Philly.

 

[Clayton]

Dude, no one even wants to hire Belichick. He isnt currently a top 35 coach

 

[saturdaysarebetter]

Yes I think Andy Reid is top 10 - 3 Super Bowl wins, 6 Super Bowl appearances, and a lot of success in both KC and Philly.

Who does he replace that's already in the top 10 of the NFL's 100th anniversary team of head coaches?

 

[Clayton]

To put Belichick in perspective, Pete Carroll was just hired.

 

[Xeliou66]

Who does he replace that's already in the top 10 of the NFL's 100th anniversary team of head coaches?

Of those listed I would say he would replace Joe Gibbs, or maybe even Belichick. Reid has had success on multiple teams with multiple QBs, Belichick hasn’t won anything without Brady and did a poor job building a team around Brady, things turned to shit in NE the minute Brady left.

 

[Yankee Traveler]

Dude, no one even wants to hire Belichick. He isnt currently a top 35 coach

Dude, no one even wants to hire Belichick. He isnt currently a top 35 coach

Joe Gibbs isn't working for anyone either...doesn't mean his record doesn't stand.

Call me when Reid gets the the Super Bowl 9 times, wins 6, and 13 AFCCG including 8 straight.

 

[Yankee Traveler]

To put Belichick in perspective, Pete Carroll was just hired.

Because Bill didn't want the Job.

UNC HC Bill Belichick has heard from multiple teams, including Raiders minority owner Tom Brady, to gauge interest in return to NFL

 

[Clayton]

Because Bill didn't want the Job.

UNC HC Bill Belichick has heard from multiple teams, including Raiders minority owner Tom Brady, to gauge interest in return to NFL

He wanted the Falcons job last year, right?

You FIRED him.

 

[Yankee Traveler]

He wanted the Falcons job last year, right?

You FIRED him.

"I" had nothing to do with it and said he shouldn't have been.

Kraft had stepped in and was making too many decisions because he is so eaten up that Jerry is in the HOF and he is not. And after he fired him he told Blank not to hire him, black balled him.

 

[Clayton]

"I" had nothing to do with it and said he shouldn't have been.

Kraft had stepped in and was making too many decisions because he is so eaten up that Jerry is in the HOF and he is not. And after he fired him he told Blank not to hire him, black balled him.

Belichicks record without Brady and Brady winning a SB right after leaving the Patriots I think raises some eyebrows.

I will concede that getting wiped out in 2 SBs is a bad look for Reid. Im not sure its actually all that bad because there might be some credit for just getting so many wins without a good OL but its still terrible optics.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

Of those listed I would say he would replace Joe Gibbs, or maybe even Belichick. Reid has had success on multiple teams with multiple QBs, Belichick hasn’t won anything without Brady and did a poor job building a team around Brady, things turned to shit in NE the minute Brady left.

One could say Reid's ultimate success is do to Mahomes cause he didn't achieve much in Philly besides stock piling regular season wins.

 

[Wamu]

Yes I think Andy Reid is top 10 - 3 Super Bowl wins, 6 Super Bowl appearances, and a lot of success in both KC and Philly.

Hell yeah he is. And how many HC's are the winningest coach for two franchises?

Anyone that says otherwise his being a homer.

 

[PolarVortex]

Pictured are the top 10 NFL head coaches as chosen for the NFL's 100th Anniversary team. Has Andy Reid now made the top 10 of all-time NFL head coaches?

If you believe yes, who does he replace?

View attachment 389398

What? That question should not need to be asked. He's made the top 5. How many head coaches have made it to 5 superbowls in a six-year stretch?

 

[Stakesarehigh]

Yes, over Gibbs

 

[UK Cowboy]

I think you could make an argument for Andy at #2 with a shot at #1 with another strong 3-4 years. He has been awesome in KC and his non Mahomes record obliterates BB's non Brady record

 

[Yankee Traveler]

Belichicks record without Brady and Brady winning a SB right after leaving the Patriots I think raises some eyebrows.

I will concede that getting wiped out in 2 SBs is a bad look for Reid. Im not sure its actually all that bad because there might be some credit for just getting so many wins without a good OL but its still terrible optics.

Don't overlook;

1) His defensive scheme in the HOF
2) His defense holding the Rams to 3

It's not all Brady.