Exploring a trade

[jeffro151]

My team
RB: Barkley, Ekeler, Gordon, Lindsay, Coleman, Malcolm Brown
WR: Evans, Thielen, Jeffery, Fitzgerald

Their team:
RB: Mccaffery, Carson, Barbee
WR: Hill, Chark, Sutton, Dorsett, John Brown, AJ Brown


I'd like to offer Evans and Lindsay for Carson and Sutton. Am I being fair, or do you think he will laugh at my offer?

 

[HaroldSeattle]

My team
RB: Barkley, Ekeler, Gordon, Lindsay, Coleman, Malcolm Brown
WR: Evans, Thielen, Jeffery, Fitzgerald

Their team:
RB: Mccaffery, Carson, Barbee
WR: Hill, Chark, Sutton, Dorsett, John Brown, AJ Brown


I'd like to offer Evans and Lindsay for Carson and Sutton. Am I being fair, or do you think he will laugh at my offer?

Oh it's fair enough, you might even regret offering it if it gets accepted, but it's no lead pipe cinch to be accepted. Redraft or dynasty? I'm guessing redraft.

 

[jeffro151]

Or maybe propose the same combo of Evans and Lindsay for Mack and Lockett to this owner:
RB: Mack, Hyde, Kerryon, Ronald Jones, Ito Smith
WR: Thomas, Adams, McLaurin, Lockett, Samuel

 

[jeffro151]

Oh it's fair enough, you might even regret offering it if it gets accepted, but it's no lead pipe cinch to be accepted. Redraft or dynasty? I'm guessing redraft.

Not a keeper league

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Or maybe propose the same combo of Evans and Lindsay for Mack and Lockett to this owner:
RB: Mack, Hyde, Kerryon, Ronald Jones, Ito Smith
WR: Thomas, Adams, McLaurin, Lockett, Samuel

Myself like this better, but as a Seahawk fan I'm biased. I take the QBs in consideration here. Wilson>Flacco there for Lockett> Sutton. I'd be inclined to hold onto Lindsey if possible myself, think he is much better then his back up and adjustments will be made to accommodate that difference, health being the wild card in his situation. Lindsay not really work horse size, but he so quick if he can survive the season he'll be a keeper.

 

[TREFF]

The way Evans has performed this year, I could certainly see it being rejected. As a Carson owner in one and an Evans in another, I certainly wouldn't feel motivated to do it.

But no, its a fair offer..I just don't think it'll work.

The Mack on likely has a better chance at success, but then again, Mack isnt Carson

 

[Sam Sportboy]

I have a feeling yer either not gonna want to deal Evans after tomorrow or you'll be able to get more fer him. Think he gets fed.

 

[wildturkey]

It's a fair offer.

Though I'd shoot for Mack/Lockett first. I'd rather have them. You'll probably get rejected once they think about it but worth a shot.

 

[femurov]

I have a feeling yer either not gonna want to deal Evans after tomorrow or you'll be able to get more fer him. Think he gets fed.

I'd be willing to stick it out with Evans. You never know when he is going to put up 40.

 

[tlance]

Offer is fair.

Like other have said, I would not rush to sell Evans low.

But both of those work if you need RB help.