Clayton ranks Dalton dead last

[flamingrey]

Cam is clearly worse right now. So yes ranking Dalton dead last is a bit of a stretch imo. Time will tell as the season goes on.....

I wouldn't say clearly. Andy has had 1 good game, and that against the worst team in the league. He isn't clearly better than anyone. Hence, it isn't a stretch that someone would rank him dead last.

 

[bengaldoug]

What I saw of Cam against our defense was clearly worse than what I saw of Dalton.... specifically, it's very clear Cam is struggling with the mental part of the game much worse than Dalton is.....his overall physical talent may eventually take over, but right now, not so much....just my opinion, though......

 

[flamingrey]

I don't think anyone would disagree with that assessment; however, just because Dalton is ahead of Cam in the mental aspect, that doesn't mean he'll be more successful even this season. I believe one could easily argue Cam's physical talent will be more beneficial to him this season than Dalton's limited mental grasp of the game combined with his physical ability to this point.

 

[bengaldoug]

Again just my opinion, but I think Cam's going to be a huge bust......of course as a card carrying fan of the Crimson Tide, I may be just a little biased......

 

[vancelot23]

Id like to not have either one if it were possible.

 

[bengaldoug]

Id like to not have either one if it were possible.

I'd like to still have Palmer, but that's pissing into the wind.....

 

[Cincyfan78]

I have to agree. The NFL is not the place to "learn" how to read a defense. Cam's running ability will be an asset to him, but right now he's simply a bigger more physically gifted Akili Smith, or an in shape Jamarcus Russel. No thanks.

Dalton reminds me more of a chad pennington. He's not going to wow you with style or anything, but he's going to be good enough. Hopefully, he can develop a better arm and get stronger as he grows.

 

[kramer1]

Dalton is never going to be "good." He stinks. He'll always stink.