Carr or Bridgewater

[Trudem]

I currently have Bridgewater stashed deep on my bench in my dynasty league but ive been considering picking up Carr of him.

What is everyone's thoughts?

 

[TxHeat]

you screwed!!!

 

[TKOSpikes]

Would love both. Anyone else you can drop? I'd take Carr if not, but like I said, having both could be large next year. And Carr could help enough this year, if your QB could attract a nice RB/WR/TE, it might be worth it.

 

[Trudem]

you screwed!!!

I dont think you were paying attention in class today.

 

[Trudem]

Would love both. Anyone else you can drop? I'd take Carr if not, but like I said, having both could be large next year. And Carr could help enough this year, if your QB could attract a nice RB/WR/TE, it might be worth it.

Well bridgewater is my 3rd QB on my roster as it is. I have Rodgers this year but he goes back but I have Cam Newton forever. I took a QB this year because I didnt know how long it would take Cam to come back from his surgery and it looks like he is finally running again.

I've dangled Rodgers to some but since I have Jordy its hard to lose that combo since they seemed locked in together.

 

[SoShady]

I would stick with Bridgewater. Depending on how long you can keep both I would just roll with Cam/Bridgewater into the future. If you can't hold Bridgewater I would consider carrying 4 for now. But only if you have huge rosters. Judging by the fact he's on the wire I would have to guess that is a no. So hold tight with the 3 you have now.

 

[The Foot]

I think you are fine with Carr. I can't promise he will be the next Aaron Rodgers but I wouldn't be shocked at all if he was. He has been watching football and learning defensive coverage, zone blitzes and the such since he was twelve, SINCE HE WAS TWELVE, when his bro entered the league. His bro has watched over him like a Large Hawk guiding him and telling him what NOT to do. This kid COULD be the REAL DEAL! I'd take a shot for sure!

 

[The Foot]

Heck I am considering starting him over Kaeps, that's how much I like him and I love Kaeps!

 

[TREFF]

I'm siding with the Foot on this one. . And it has nothing to do with my membership in Raidernation, as I've been a big supporter of Bridgewater. But Carr has the look of potential superstar in my eyes. I think either way, you'll have a strong QB in the years to come, but I think Carr ends up being the better of the two

 

[Trudem]

QBs: Rodgers, Newton(K), Bridgewater(K)
RBs: Forte, Ball(K), J. Bell(K), Helu(K), Taliaferro(K), Freeman(K) and Mojo(K)
WRs: Bryant, Nelson(K), Benjamin(K), Cooks(K) and Patterson(K)
TE: Thomas(K)
Def: Seattle(K)

Doghouse: AP

Mojo and Taliaferro can be dropped as needed but since AP is an idiot my RB situation is paper thin ive tried to stockpile as many as possible.

 

[TKOSpikes]

I'd grab Carr, drop MJD and really look for a Rodgers for RB deal.

 

[TKOSpikes]

Actually with Cam's keeper status, may be he can get someone too. I wouldn't be scared going into 2015 with Carr and Bridge. And if you do, well you can always draft another Rodgers type early.

 

[wilwhite]

I've been high on Carr as the best long-term fantasy QB of these rookies for a while, and nothing has changed. He's got leadership, accuracy, and makes good decisions (adjusting for rookiedom), which is what you're looking for. He is also establishing himself as the face of the franchise and they'll build around him. Minny's future is more mysterious, and I'm not as high on Bridgewater anyway.

 

[huskers1217]

I stashed away Bortles for next year.

Bridgewater will be an average QB and Carr won't get the proper coaching to succeed in Oakland.

 

[Trudem]

I just worry about Carr disappearing because he plays in Oakland...no offense Treff

 

[wilwhite]

Don't forget that Al Davis is dead.

 

[Trudem]

Don't forget that Al Davis is dead.

still rolling through coaches at the same pace but yes that is true.