Best QB of All Time Game 2

[Nosferatu]

Brett Favre vs Warren Moon

Vote and Discuss...

 

[HammerDown]

"This poll is racist!" - Warren Moon

 

[Wazmankg]

This one is easier, but I'm the only one to vote Favre so far ? He gets a lot of hate .. especially in recent years but he was better than Moon. Look up the numbers folks.

 

[Smart]

Neither one of these deserve to be anywhere near the top eight. Favre was consistent when it came to taking the field, but made way too many mistakes. Warren Moon was 102-101 in his career with a QB Rating of 80. I'm a loss at how Aaron Rodgers isn't in the sixteen, because he stomps either one of these.

 

[SteelersPride]

gotta go moon, favre was good though, favre just was having fun out there

 

[Nosferatu]

Neither one of these deserve to be anywhere near the top eight. Favre was consistent when it came to taking the field, but made way too many mistakes. Warren Moon was 102-101 in his career with a QB Rating of 80. I'm a loss at how Aaron Rodgers isn't in the sixteen, because he stomps either one of these.

Just my opinion but i'd kinda like to see Rodgers do it for more than 5 years before I put him up there.

 

[WhiteMamba]

Warren Moon? Huck that FUSKY!!!!

Favre by a wide margin

 

[mrwallace2ku]

Farve vote here...again an escape artist who threw where he wanted, when he wanted.

 

[Wazmankg]

This is a shocker. It shouldn't be all that close much less Moon winning.

 

[4down20]

who the fuck is voting for moon?

 

[Smart]

Just my opinion but i'd kinda like to see Rodgers do it for more than 5 years before I put him up there.

Sorry, but Troy Aikman and Steve Young made it. Young was a starter for eight years. Aikman was thoroughly awful outside of five years when he was surrounded by the best supporting cast in the league. Rodgers has given six incredible seasons.

Rodgers has the highest QB Rating in NFL History. He won a Super Bowl. He went 15-1 behind a terrible offensive line. Rodgers on his worst day puts both of these two to shame. I'm all for consistency, but if you want the best player, you gotta go Rodgers.

 

[Nosferatu]

Fair enough and like I said I gave everyone a chance to tell me who should be on and or off the list.

 

[HammerDown]

Favre isn't even the best QB in Packers history. He was a gunslinger but doesn't deserve mention with the greats. Easily one of the most overrated athletes in American pro sports history.

I'd like to replace Favre and Brees both with Steve McNair. I shoulda piped up when I had the chance.

 

[calsnowskier]

How is it that one of these guys advance, but either Young or Brady will be eliminated?

 

[Nosferatu]

How is it that one of these guys advance, but either Young or Brady will be eliminated?

 

[tzorn10]

Took Moon. I also agree Favre was overrated.

 

[Wazmankg]

I would love to hear the case for Moon > Favre.

 

[HammerDown]

How is it that one of these guys advance, but either Young or Brady will be eliminated?

"It doesn't matter anyway. Hammer's in the background changing votes." - Waz

 

[Nosferatu]

"It doesn't matter anyway. Hammer's in the background changing votes." - Waz

While you're doing that could ya change some of the players too?

 

[broncosmitty]

who the fuck is voting for moon?

Me! Favre's "Gunslinger" bullshit was just as good at winning close games as it was losing 'em. Most Picks.....Evah!!! (I don't like either of these guys to win another matchup.)