Barkley DONE for year

[Shanemansj13]

Personally I wouldn’t go early on a wr and take the risk with a rb. I think you should take a rb cuz you use them more and rely on them more play in and play out as oppose to a wr. Yes a wr u can use for every pass play and can tear apart a defense. But an explosive RB can tear a defense a part both on running plays and you can put them out as a wr and they can hurt you there too.
But at the end of the day yes I do feel bad for Barkley. Two years in a row going out with injuries. Who knows if he will ever be the same after this injury. And how many years in his prime is he missing due to injury.

I wouldn't take either early. Lineman or QB (if needed) is usually the best play. So lets say they pass up Barkley, they would have the choice of:

Bradley Chubb
Denzel Ward
Quenton Nelson
Roquan Smith

Not bad.

 

[RobBase]

That’s why you don’t waste a top 3 pick on a RB.

 

[RobBase]

I wouldn't take either early. Lineman or QB (if needed) is usually the best play. So lets say they pass up Barkley, they would have the choice of:

Bradley Chubb
Denzel Ward
Quenton Nelson
Roquan Smith

Not bad.

All would have helped the Giants much more.