RoboticDreams
JM8CH10
So you admit right now that Wilson is better than Luck?
So you admit right now that Wilson is better than Luck?
he beat him head on already
No, and I'm a Wiscondin alumni who loves Wilson. I also had season tickets the year Seattle's offensive coordinator won the first Rose Bowl in forever for Wisconsin. I'm saying that I think people too often confuse performing better for a better team as sign that one player out of 52 is better. I think Luck also would have won a Super Bowl with Seattle this year and Wilson would not be a current Super Bowl champion if he were playing for Indianapolis.
How about this...excluding QBs...who else is the most untouchable player in the league?
Robert Quinn? Earl Thomas? Luke Kuechly? Richard Sherman? JJ Watt?
How about this...excluding QBs...who else is the most untouchable player in the league?
Robert Quinn? Earl Thomas? Luke Kuechly? Richard Sherman? JJ Watt?
I agree, luck will be a top five qb for many years. Wilson may not even be a starting qb in five years.
Still haven't seen any sound argument proving that Luck is better than Wilson
It is so early in their careers that its a moot point. The Colts rely much more on Luck than Seattle does Wilson. That may change as the years go by.
This is one of those completely subjective discussions where everyone will have a different opinion..... Similar to a goat discussion. there is nothing to `prove `' and its not just the fans that will have a variety of opinions. You could ask every front office person the same question and get a bunch of different opinions.
When someone brought up Rodgers, I thought about it, and I honestly do think that all 32 GMs would take Rodgers over Luck and Wilson. You've got at least 6 elite seasons left out of him, and they haven't reached elite status yet. So ask yourself this: Would you rather have 6 elite seasons right away, or go with a young gun who's still maturing and you'll end up getting about the same amount if he develops. And surely there is going to be a great QB separate themselves and be a #1 overall draft prospect within the next 10 years.
Luck's results have not matched the hype so far. I need to see more from him to consider him most untradeable.
WTF has Luck ever won? Seriously if he is SO good why did he throw 7 INTs in 2 postseason games?
The Colts didn't have any business being in the playoffs in the first place. That team had one of the worst supporting casts both on offense & defense I've ever seen in a playoff team much less a divisional winner. They had like 19 guys on IR to boot.
What has he ever won? He took the worst team in the NFL to the playoffs as a rookie, and he won a playoff game in his 2nd year on a piss-poor team. That's damn good.