Aldon Smith or D'qwell Jackson? Keeper league!

[The Foot]

Who would you guys choose ina full keeper.

Aldon is younger but one more slip up and he could be gone for a very long time.

or

D'quell Jackson - He jumped teams and is now with the Colts does he stay productive.

If you could pick only one with everything else being equall who would you rather have?

 

[averagejoe]

Smith is not a good choice. He is facing 3 felony weapons charges and a DUI.

Ex-Bear Tank Johnson just had a single weapons charge in 2007 and had an 8-game suspension. Plus, I believe that Smith is a repeat offender.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

also - Smith pled guilty to those charges today. could be facing jail time, on top of any suspensions that the league passes down.

Side note - in a full keeper, why are you even deciding this? or are those guys FA's right now in your league? or just part of a trade you are working?

 

[The Foot]

part of a trade. I have Smith but am really on the fense cause we can keep these players forever and I figure even of Smith loses this entire year he still is only 24 years old. Jackson is up there in age at 29 or 30 but i was consodering it because I am a little thin at inside linebacker. In our league we specify inside and outside.