PolarVortex
Nanook of the North
If he had remained a catcher and accomplished those stats, he'd have a shot. But 40% of his career starts have been at first base or DH.joe mauer:
thru age 30:
1178 games
1414 hits (averaged 141 per season)
105 HR
634 RBI
.323 avg
.873 OPS
3 batting titles, 1 MVP, one great commercial line, on the path to the HOF
after age 30:
506 games
504 hits (averages 126 per season)
30 HR
212 RBI
.268 avg
.733 OPS
nowhere near cooperstown