7 HOF, CY or MVP Players MLB Draft QF3 : UK vs Hall

[Nosferatu]

UK

LINEUP vs RHSP
1. *Pete Rose (B) - 2B
2. *George Brett (L) - 3B
3. *Mickey Mantle (B) - CF
4. Carlos Beltran (B) - RF
5. Todd Helton (L) - 1B
6. Will Clark (L) - DH
7. Mickey Tettleton (B) - C
8. Jose Cruz (L) - LF
9. Jose Valentin (B) - SS

LINEUP vs LHSP
1. *Pete Rose (B) - 2B
2. *George Brett (L) - 3B
3. *Mickey Mantle (B) - CF
4. *Ralph Kiner (R) - LF
5. Carlos Beltran (B) - RF
6. Andres Galarraga (R) - 1B
7.*Mike Piazza (R) - C
8. Moises Alou (R) - DH
9. Al Dark (R) - SS

ROTATION
1. *Lefty Grove (L)
2. *Bob Gibson (R)
3. Sam McDowell (L)
4. J.R. Richard (R)
5. John Tudor (L)

BULLPEN
Billy Wagner (L)
Armando Benitez (R)
Rick Aguilera (R)
B.J. Ryan (L)
Jeff Russell (R)

VS

HALL

LINEUP vs RHSP
1. 'Shoeless' Joe Jackson - LF
2. Charlie Gehringer - 2B
3. Johnny Mize - 1B
4. Frank Thomas - DH
5. Hank Aaron - RF
6. Edgar Martinez - 3B
7. Jorge Posada - C
8. Derek Jeter - SS
9. Johnny Damon - CF

LINEUP vs LHSP
1. Derek Jeter - SS
2. Edgar Martinez - 3B
3. Hank Aaron - RF
4. Frank Thomas - DH
5. Frank Howard - LF
6. Bernie Williams - CF
7. Pedro Guerrero - 1B
8. Gene Tenace - C
9. Davey Lopes - 2B

ROTATION
1. *Greg Maddux (R)
2. *Tom Glavine (L)
3. Curt Schilling (R)
4. Dave Stieb (R)
5. Tim Hudson (R)

BULLPEN
Tug McGraw (L)
John Wetteland (R)
Arthur Rhodes (L)
Jeff Nelson (R)
Rob Dibble (R)

 

[Nosferatu]

UK - 4
HALL - 6

VOTED - UK, Shane, Ritzy, Milk, Mookie, Ducey, Femur, 500, Stakes, Hall

Race to 6

 

[Shanemansj13]

Another nice matchup. UK

 

[UK Cowboy]

UK

 

[Ritzarmy]

UK in a tight matchup

 

[MilkSpiller22]

i like Hall's non HOFers much better....

I got hall...

 

[Mookie]

Man these are all so close. Hall

 

[tducey]

Hall

 

[femurov]

UK

 

[Stakesarehigh]

Hall

 

[Hall]

Hall for sure :p.

Jeter, Edgar, Aaron, Frank, and Howard is a murderers row for Lefties.

 

[Pack 500]

Hall

 

[Shanemansj13]

Hall for sure :p.

Jeter, Edgar, Aaron, Frank, and Howard is a murderers row for Lefties.

You definitely got the benefit of playing 3 lefties in this matchup. Here is obp and ops...

1. Derek Jeter - SS - .401, .893
2. Edgar Martinez - 3B - .443, .982
3. Hank Aaron - RF - .405, 1.008
4. Frank Thomas - DH - .448, 1.083
5. Frank Howard - LF - .401, .982
6. Bernie Williams - CF - .397, .900
7. Pedro Guerrero - 1B - .374, .850
8. Gene Tenace - C - .408, .870
9. Davey Lopes - 2B - .376, .831

Total: .405, .933

1. *Pete Rose (B) - 2B - .384, .804
2. *George Brett (L) - 3B - .388, .906
3. *Mickey Mantle (B) - CF - .418, .998
4. Carlos Beltran (B) - RF - .353, .834
5. Todd Helton (L) - 1B - .414, 1.001
6. Will Clark (L) - DH - .400, .925
7. Mickey Tettleton (B) - C - .376, .821
8. Jose Cruz (L) - LF - .372, .813
9. Jose Valentin (B) - SS - .331, .816

Total: .381, .879

Overall the OPS is about the difference in Mookie's matchup as well so then you have to look at the rotation and see if the difference is enough to get the win. Also, this is just 3 games, 2 games you would face his RHP and he would only face your LHP once.

You could argue Mook had a better rotation than yours but it's close, I actually like yours by a hair but I still think UK's rotation is better than both but it's close.

1. *Steve Carlton (L)
2. *Nolan Ryan (R)
3. Dave Stewart (R)
4. Mark Langston (L)
5. Josh Beckett (R)

1. *Greg Maddux (R)
2. *Tom Glavine (L)
3. Curt Schilling (R)
4. Dave Stieb (R)
5. Tim Hudson (R)

This matchup is very close. You have the advantage with your lineup and the fact you face his lefties 3 times and he has the rotation imo. BP's are close.

Most of these matchups have been great, all really close, no lopsided matchups. Nice win Hall

 

[Shanemansj13]

Obviously, there is more to hitting than obp and ops just didn't want to breakout every stat FYI