2018 AP Overrated/Underrated contest

[belcherboy]

Heh, I'm in the same boat.

I got Wisconsin as overrated, which is fine, but then I got 0-3 UCLA as underrated.

0-4. I thought Chip would have had something up his sleeve to at least get them one win so far this season.

 

[outofyourmind]

I have Oklahoma State as underrated.
I'm in trouble

 

[Edisto_Tiger]

Edisto_Tiger Overrated #12 Notre Dame Underrated #26 Florida

Damn, I shit the bed on this one.

 

[xpuctaqpGT]

Edisto_Tiger Overrated #12 Notre Dame Underrated #26 Florida

Damn, I shit the bed on this one.

Yeah....picking someone outside of the top 10 as overrated is an um...bold move. You may still get some points from UF though.

 

[tnapucco]

There were a lot of people who picked #8 Miami as overrated.

Yeah...but only one picked Syracuse as their underrated.

 

[tnapucco]

 

[TJabroni]

TJabroni overrated #4 Wisconsin Underrated #26 Florida

 

[NolePride]

Is it too late to post my selections?

 

[Scapegoat]

Picks updated as of 6:08pm Fri Aug 24, 2018

Picks are due 10pm TONIGHT!!!!!!


If you don't see your picks, reformat and try again...


7samurai13 overrated #8 Miami underrated #26 Northwestern
963bUSC Overrated - #4 Wisconsin Underrated #26 Arizona
B_dub Overrated #16 TCU Underrated #24 Oregon
batchaps4me. overrated #8 Miami , underrated #18 Mississippi State
belcherboy overrated #10 Penn State underrated #26 Arizona
BigFin overrated #16 TCU underrated #19 Florida St.
Blackshirts, overrated #8 Miami, underrated #26 Nebraska
Boise4Life overrated #8 Miami underrated #25 LSU
BoiseMike19 Overrated #8 Miami, Underrated #22 Boise State
BoiseStateFan27 - Overrated #9 Auburn Underrated #26 Utah

BTHOtu Overrated #6 Washington Underrated #26 Texas A&M
BusSport Overrated is #4 Wisconsin Underrated is #26 UCLA
Chewbaccer overrated #8 Miami Underrated #26 South Carolina
ckhokie overrated #10 Penn St underrated #26 Boston College
CorpRebel overrated #8 Miami Underrated #23 Texas
cwalke3408 Overrated #11 Michigan St. Underrated #26 South Carolina
cwerph, Overrated #8 Miami, Underrated, #25 LSU
Deep Creek Overrated #16 TCU Underrated #26 Florida
ericd7633: overrated #9 Auburn; underrated #26 Boston College.
GeekSportsFan overrated...#6 Washington underrated.....#15 USC

Innermind overrated #6 Washington underrated #26 Iowa
iowajerms overrated - #8 Miami underrated #26 Iowa
Jon2tanman ,Overrated #21 UCF. Underrated #26 Arizona
Justin Tyme overrated #6 Washington underrated #26 Arizonia
jwolt92 overrated #8 Miami underrated #26 FAU
kburjr overrated #9 Auburn underrated #26 Iowa
KingKoolKat75 Overrated #8 Miami Underrated #24 Texas
Knightandday. Overrated #5 Ohio St., Underrated #26 South Carolina
lilchi721 Overrated #23 Texas Underrated #26 A&M
Moab - overrated #8 Miami - underrated #26 Northwestern

MonkeyPoo #4 Wisconsin Overrated #26 NC State
nddulax overrated. #8 Miam (Fl) underrated. #26 Duke
Obxyankeefan Overrated Georgia #3 Underrated Purdue #26
outofyourmind overrated #2 Clemson underrated #26 Oklahoma State
pedro3252 overrated #9 Auburn underrated #26 Florida
Pitman - overrated #4 Wisconsin underrated #26 NC State
Ralphiewvu overrated #7 Oklahoma underrated #17 West Virginia
Rmilia1 Overrated #7 Oklahoma Underrated #26 Iowa
Scapegoat--Overrated-#11Michigan State; Underrated- #26Washington State
Smart Overrated #9 Auburn Underrated #25 LSU

Socaljim242 overrated #8 Miami underrated #23 Texas
The Derski Overrated #6 Washington; Underrated #26 Arizona
TheDayMan overrated #12 Notre Dame underrated #26 UCLA
Tin Man overrated #8 Miami underrated #26 Tennessee
tnapucco overrated #8 Miami Underrated #26 Syracuse
Trench Mob - Overrated: #4 Wisconsin. Underrated: #26 Navy.
TrustMeIAmRight — #8 Miami overrated #25 LSU underrated
tnapucco overrated #8 Miami Underrated #26 Syracuse
uncfan103 overrated #4 Wisconsin underrated #26 South Carolina
wingsauce7. overrated. #11. Michigan St. underrated. #26. Iowa

xpuctaqpGT overrated #4 Wisconsin Underrated #26 Georgia Tech

In case anyone forgot.

 

[wingsauce7]

Scapegoat--Overrated-#11Michigan State; Underrated- #26Washington State

pretty good call there.

 

[Deep Creek]

Deep Creek Overrated #16 TCU Underrated #26 Florida

But Florida ain't as good as they are currently rated!

 

[7Samurai13]

Well I should have two positives at worst so I got that going for me.

 

[rsw626]

Underrated: Kirby Smart’s ability to think he’s Les Miles going for a fake punt.

Overrated: Kirby Smart’s ability to actually be Les Miles and succeed in said fake punt.

 

[Chewbaccer]

Underrated: Kirby Smart’s ability to think he’s Les Miles going for a fake punt.

Overrated: Kirby Smart’s ability to actually be Les Miles and succeed in said fake punt.

I don't mind the decision to go for it. The playcall sucked, but the decision to go for it at midfield didn't. Our defense was done. We punt the ball, Bama is still gonna score, only we're not gonna get the ball back with a minute left, at least not with 2 timeouts.

But at any rate, Tennessee would cream their jeans for a season like the Dawgs had with the youngest roster in the SEC.

 

[rsw626]

I don't mind the decision to go for it. The playcall sucked, but the decision to go for it at midfield didn't. Our defense was done. We punt the ball, Bama is still gonna score, only we're not gonna get the ball back with a minute left, at least not with 2 timeouts.

But at any rate, Tennessee would cream their jeans for a season like the Dawgs had with the youngest roster in the SEC.

Tennessee being shit right now has no bearing on it being a stupid call and handing the game to Bama.

 

[Chewbaccer]

Tennessee being shit right now has no bearing on it being a stupid call and handing the game to Bama.

Punting it away would have handed the game to Bama too, only either leaving us far less clock or no timeouts when we did get the ball back if we got it back at all. Defense was done. Should have called a better play, but I don't mind going for it there at all.

 

[TheDayMan]

I picked Notre Dame as overrated and UCLA as underrated.

 

[Boise4Life]

Boise4Life overrated #8 Miami underrated #25 LSU

Got it.

 

[BoiseStateFan27]

Having Auburn as overrated was a good pick, though not better than others

Utah at least seems like they might finish the year ranked, so that's a solid underrated pick

 

[BusSport]

@xpuctaqpGT

Final AP poll is out... can we get the results for this contest?