2013 HOF Ballot

[tzill]

I see what you did there but, FAIL

I just couldn't leave Ty Cobb, the fourth best player EVER, off my team. However, it does occur to me that Bonds, Mays, and ARod would probably kill him in the first week of playing together so...problem solved.

 

[msgkings322]

I just couldn't leave Ty Cobb, the fourth best player EVER, off my team. However, it does occur to me that Bonds, Mays, and ARod would probably kill him in the first week of playing together so...problem solved.

Exactly. Or he'd just up and have a heart attack when he saw all those types outplaying him.

Personally I rank Williams ahead of Cobb, his already amazing stats woulda been even better if he hadn't been a freaking war hero TWICE. And he had to face Latins and blacks.

 

[Stokes1931]

No vote for Shawn Green as a sympathy vote for tzill?

Gotta represent the tribe.

 

[coffeeman]

Just for fun, my greatest players all time by position:

P -- Ruth
C -- Bench
1B -- Musial
2B -- Hornsby
SS -- Wagner
3B -- ARod
LF -- Bonds
CF -- Mays
RF -- Cobb

I think there is only one argument to the above: Schmidt at 3b.

Not bad. I think i would go Gehrig at 1st but it's close.

 

[Mays-Fan]

I just couldn't leave Ty Cobb, the fourth best player EVER, off my team. However, it does occur to me that Bonds, Mays, and ARod would probably kill him in the first week of playing together so...problem solved.

None of us could stand the sonofabitch when he was alive so we told him to stick it! Heh-heh-heh-heh-heh !!!!!!