2011 Heisman

[uncfan103]

Would anybody be interested in voting for who they think deserves the Heisman every week or two. Pick like a top 3 or 5 or whatever, and then at the end of the year have a SportsHoopla Heisman winner?

 

[vancelot23]

Andrew Luck.

 

[WoodyHayes1951]

Andrew Luck would probably run away with it.

Although if Kellen Moore was actually on TV he'd be in the conversation.

 

[axisoftime]

Luck already won. mark it, dude

 

[uncfan103]

Luck will probably win, but im not sure if Luck would win if the people of SportsHoopla voted and came up with who we think deserves the Heisman. I feel like Richardson would get a lot of tSEC votes and that we all watch enough football and have opinions other than that of the media.

 

[Smart]

I'll give mine:

1. Russell Wilson
2. Case Keenum
3. Trent Richardson
4. Andrew Luck
5. Kellen Moore

Just out: RG3 and Sammy Watkins

 

[uncfan103]

Ill go...
1. Russell Wilson
2. Case Keenum
3. Trent Richardson
4. Tyrann Mathieu
5. Joseph Randle

Luck, Moore, LaMichael James could all easily end up top 5.

 

[vancelot23]

Top 5

1. Andrew Luck
2. Trent Richardson
3. Tyrunn Mathieu
4. Kellen Moore
5. Russell Wilson

 

[BadMotoWeazal]

If Trent R is able to run all over the LSD defense, would that give him a bump?

 

[uncfan103]

If Trent R is able to run all over the LSD defense, would that give him a bump?

Yeah, I would bump him up over Keenum for sure.

 

[Brasky]

Rex Burkhead

 

[ugafan6612]

Luck(If Stanford wins out)
Trent Richardson(If Bama wins out)
Tyrann Mathieu(If LSU wins out)
Those are the only 3 that have a chance right now. Although Mathieu probably wouldn't get it being on defense

I'd vote Kellen Moore but it won't happen.
Case Keenum has never beaten anyone good.

 

[BadMotoWeazal]

RB's & WR's have a bit of an issue with winning the heisman... QB stays in pretty much all game, RB's gets a breather, shares a backfield & sits down in the 4th when the games in hand (well QB's get this too, but not as often)

 

[uncfan103]

Luck(If Stanford wins out)
Trent Richardson(If Bama wins out)
Tyrann Mathieu(If LSU wins out)
Those are the only 3 that have a chance right now. Although Mathieu probably wouldn't get it being on defense

I'd vote Kellen Moore but it won't happen.
Case Keenum has never beaten anyone good.

I dont even think Mathieu has a shot, especially after he got suspended for a game. I think it comes down to Luck and Richardson. I wanted to make this thread about who we think should win, not who is going to win.

 

[bchampy]

Luck(If Stanford wins out)
Trent Richardson(If Bama wins out)
Tyrann Mathieu(If LSU wins out)
Those are the only 3 that have a chance right now. Although Mathieu probably wouldn't get it being on defense

I'd vote Kellen Moore but it won't happen.
Case Keenum has never beaten anyone good.

Why do the teams need to win for a player to receive an individual award?

 

[bchampy]

1. Kellen Moore
2. Andrew Luck
3. Trent Richardson
4. Russell Wilson
5. Tajh Boyd

 

[BoiseStateFan27]

1. Kellen Moore
2. Andrew Luck
3. Robert Griffin III(hey not his fault his line sucks)
4. Russell Wilson
5. Trent Richardson

close: Case Keenum, Joseph Randle, Ryan Broyles, Bobby Rainey.

 

[Smoke]

Braxton Miller. EOT.

 

[rolltide14_0]

My top 3...

1. Trent Richardson (He was held to 77 yards on the ground vs UT, but some think this was one of his best games. Yards aside, he made some very nice plays in this game.)

2. Andrew Luck (I really like Luck, he's by far the best QB in the nation in my opinion. But his pick 6 against USC nearly cost his team the game. Some people say it's what he did after the pick that makes him stay at #1, but in my opinion, if not for a personal foul penalty on USC, it would've been 4th and long for Stanford, and USC likely would've won in regulation.)

3. Brandon Weeden (All I can say is he's damn good. I'd say right there with Andrew Luck. If Stanford loses and Alabama loses, it wouldn't surprise me to see him win the Heisman, providing he continues to play great and beat OU.)

Past this you can pretty much list them however you want. Kellen Moore and Case Keenum aren't gonna come close to winning it because of their schedules. Russell Wilsons team has lost twice in a row now, and regardless or how he played in those games, he's likely screwed now. RG3, he continues to put up good numbers while losing, but same deal as Russel Wilson, you gotta win. Sammy Watkins ain't gonna win it because he's a WR, I don't even know why people even mention him. Also in the same boat as Sammy Watkins is Tyrann Mathieu, he's a defensive player/SP. He's not gonna win it. Then you got Lamicheal James, I don't think he's gonna win it as long as Alabama keeps winning, because as long as Richardson is in it, it probably won't go to a quickster like James.