Who wins this deal?

[Trudem]

Andrew Luck and Jeremy Maclin

For

Cam Newton, Victor Cruz and Rashad Jennings?

This is a dynasty league with standard scoring.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Team B

Cam newton is not much worse than Andrew luck, and they are both young...

Victor cruz is right now better than maclin, but philly offense might make maclin near elite this season...

Its all about the xtra piece in Jennings... Even in dynasties you still have to play for now, and if you dont someone else will... Jennings has enough value to net you something in a trade this season...

 

[tlance]

I actually think Newton is equal to or better than Luck, so I take B in a landslide.

 

[Trudem]

Thanks that is my thinking too. My brother in law fails to see this as a one sided offer

 

[Trudem]

What about subbing Harvin for Maclin. IMO it doesn't make a big difference

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I actually think Newton is equal to or better than Luck, so I take B in a landslide.

Its just that in a dynasty potential is still a factor, Luck is still more appealing than newton... But i agree...

 

[MilkSpiller22]

What about subbing Harvin for Maclin. IMO it doesn't make a big difference

Would probably rather have maclin than harvin!!! Harvin is great, but he jsut cant stay healthy...

 

[TKOSpikes]

Would probably rather have maclin than harvin!!! Harvin is great, but he jsut cant stay healthy...

neither can Maclin...

This deal is lopsided either way. Harvin makes it closer, but the Cam side gets a freebie RB who might just have a very productive handful of years as a G-man.

 

[tlance]

Its just that in a dynasty potential is still a factor, Luck is still more appealing than newton... But i agree...

I don't necessarily agree that Luck has more long term upside. Newton is pretty damn good and very young.

 

[Trudem]

Cam is one year older and Luck has much better weapons. I have Cam but was looking into Luck because of his skill players. I have both Jennings and Moreno so I don't think I need both.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I don't necessarily agree that Luck has more long term upside. Newton is pretty damn good and very young.

Its not just potential, it is also the overall perception... Luck definitely has a higher perceived(by the majority fantasy football players) Potential... ANd therefore gets more value in trade... Not to mention Nobody likes Cam, and everyone likes Luck...

This may just be my opinion, but keeper leagues and dynasty league keeper value are all about their value in a trade..

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Cam is one year older and Luck has much better weapons. I have Cam but was looking into Luck because of his skill players. I have both Jennings and Moreno so I don't think I need both.

dont be afraid of depth in the preseason...

 

[TREFF]

I wholeheartedly agree with Tlance..Cam is every bit the fantasy QB that Luck is, and I don't think potential is on Luck's side either. Both have plenty of room to improve.
Cruz/Maclin/Harvin.. is about a wash either way. And as says before the real kicker is Jennings.

 

[TREFF]

Cam is one year older and Luck has much better weapons. I have Cam but was looking into Luck because of his skill players. I have both Jennings and Moreno so I don't think I need both.

well first off, just because you don't need them doesn't mean you should give them away.
Secondly if you're going to give one away. . Let it be Moreno. The guy was nothing more than a product of Peyton Manning. He won't enjoy near the success in Miami. Jennings on the other hand, broke out in Oakland of all places, where there was NOTHING around him. If either has a better shot at sustaining what they did last year it's Jennings by a landslide

 

[leftypower]

well first off, just because you don't need them doesn't mean you should give them away.
Secondly if you're going to give one away. . Let it be Moreno. The guy was nothing more than a product of Peyton Manning. He won't enjoy near the success in Miami. Jennings on the other hand, broke out in Oakland of all places, where there was NOTHING around him. If either has a better shot at sustaining what they did last year it's Jennings by a landslide

 

[The Foot]

Id take side B I think Luck gets why to much love and I dont know that he deserves it all yet.

 

[Chef99]

Id take side B I think Luck gets why to much love and I dont know that he deserves it all yet.

I think it's the name. Everyone needs a little Luck now and then.

That said, I vote for side B.

 

[SteelersPride]

team b, period

 

[Trudem]

thanks guys. I agree that the Cam Newton side is clearly the heavier side.