Best QB in the NFL

[KwitYerWhinin]

You mean the 17th rated qb in the league? um....... NO He's still good but not the best anymore

and Rogers isnt rated 22nd ??

 

[packfancjh]

and Rogers isnt rated 22nd ??

Where the hell did you get that number? He has the 4th best qb rating right now

 

[Money]

and Rogers isnt rated 22nd ??

Ummm...no. He's not.

 

[Oldschool739]

Aaron Rodgers

Right now it's the SB MVP til someone unseats him....Joe Cool Flacco !!!!
If you're talking about who's playing the best so far this year, it's Peyton Manning....
If you're talking about who is the most accomplished career wise, it's Brady, when you consider he didn't grow up with a pro bowl qb father and brothers also in football to teach him the game and still has more SB wins.
Really hard to separate those 2, but AR is not even in their class at all....

 

[Shanemansj13]

Drew Brees isn't, Hammer?

But seriously it is between Peyton and Tom. You decide, bc I can't right now

 

[sonnyblack65]

Right now it's the SB MVP til someone unseats him....Joe Cool Flacco !!!!
If you're talking about who's playing the best so far this year, it's Peyton Manning....
If you're talking about who is the most accomplished career wise, it's Brady, when you consider he didn't grow up with a pro bowl qb father and brothers also in football to teach him the game and still has more SB wins.
Really hard to separate those 2, but AR is not even in their class at all....

Oldskool ^^ Keeping it real nice.

 

[packfancjh]

Holy shit!! Not in their class? Right now it's Flacco who has a career high in interceptions going for him right now and a career low in passer rating?

 

[Shanemansj13]

But right now 2013 FULL season it's Peyton. Then Russell Wilson.

 

[sonnyblack65]

But right now 2013 FULL season it's Peyton. Then Russell Wilson.

I agree Peyton's too lose for this year. I still have Denver vs Seattle in SB with Seahawks winning

 

[Oldschool739]

Holy shit!! Not in their class? Right now it's Flacco who has a career high in interceptions going for him right now and a career low in passer rating?

Joe is the reigning SB Champion MVP all year long...
And AR took 3 years on the bench behind 1 of the best all time qb's and 3 years as starter to accomplish anything.....
Peyton was thrown in the fire day 1 and took only 1 yr for everyone to know who he was.
Brady took 1 game and the rest is history....
Joe was thrown in the fire from day 1 and so far has made the playoffs 5 straight ,6 as it stands now. 3 AFCCG's and a SB win.....And has never missed a start.....
AR has matched him in 1 area only, 1 SB win, that's it.

 

[packfancjh]

Flacco can thank his defense for getting him all those wins because he sucked ass until last years playoff run. What does AR sitting behind Favre have anything to do with how good he is. MM wanted to start him but the old man wouldn't retire. Out of Rodgers hands. Oh and look at all the records AR has achieved compared to Fuck up Flacco. Don't forget that Rodgers went to the SB in his 3rd year as a starter. It took Flacco 5

 

[Skin'EmAll]

I love RGIII.

I've always felt like it was Manning at the top.
Now, seeing what Brady has done with nothing and the loss of his two TE's...I can finally put aside the denial, he's #1.
I finally get it.

Manning is the clear cut 2nd, IMO. Rogers 3rd.

 

[Oldschool739]

Flacco can thank his defense for getting him all those wins because he sucked ass until last years playoff run. What does AR sitting behind Favre have anything to do with how good he is. MM wanted to start him but the old man wouldn't retire. Out of Rodgers hands. Oh and look at all the records AR has achieved compared to Fuck up Flacco. Don't forget that Rodgers went to the SB in his 3rd year as a starter. It took Flacco 5

You aren't the sharpest knife in the drawer are you ?....AR had the luxury of sitting and learning how to play qb at a HOF level for 3 yrs.....If you don't think that is an advantage, you need help dude !
And Joe had no one to sit under and learn but went to the AFCCG rookie yr. How many yrs as a starter did it take AR ? ...Yea I thought so....
And the last time I checked, every successful qb has a team of players around him that helps him do it... There are no exceptions to that fact.....AR is a really good qb, and so is Joe....Neither are in PM and TB's class, period !!

 

[Steelboy84]

If you mean currently and not entire career, then Rodgers slightly over Manning.

 

[The Derski]

Rodgers

 

[Champ]

Rodgers definitely.

 

[packfancjh]

So you're trying to say I'm not the sharpest knife when you're trying to argue that Flacco is the top qb this year? You're a special kind of stupid aren't ya. AR didn't learn shit from Favre. If he did he'd be throwing interceptions at every important moment of the game. Flacco got to where he is by having a top defense to keep the other team from scoring. If AR isn't even close to the other two how did he achieve some of the records he has like the being the NFL's all-time career leader in passer rating during the regular season, third overall in post season passer rating, lowest career pass interception percentage for quarterbacks during the regular season and the ONLY qb to have a career rating over 100?

 

[The Derski]

You aren't the sharpest knife in the drawer are you ?....AR had the luxury of sitting and learning how to play qb at a HOF level for 3 yrs.....If you don't think that is an advantage, you need help dude !
And Joe had no one to sit under and learn but went to the AFCCG rookie yr. How many yrs as a starter did it take AR ? ...Yea I thought so....
And the last time I checked, every successful qb has a team of players around him that helps him do it... There are no exceptions to that fact.....AR is a really good qb, and so is Joe....Neither are in PM and TB's class, period !!

Flacco definitely is not in Manning or Brady's class but Rodgers certainly is. So you got half of that right.

 

[Dude]

It's about playing against adversity too. Flacco has a very good rating and winning season % but Baltimore has been a very solid TEAM throughout his years there. Both Brady and Manning have faced adversity, in terms of not having a strong D, and they keep on delivering, racking up stats, winning games, etc.

 

[Southieinnc]

I'd bet Denver would trade Peyton for Rodgers in a heartbeat.
I'd bet Baltimore would trade Flacco for Tannehill