- Thread starter
- #1
IndyAndy
I can't reMember
- 4,470
- 179
- 63
- Joined
- Nov 13, 2012
- Hoopla Cash
- $ 545.78
Topic came up during the Detroit/Minnesota game last night, thanks to a Red Wings goal that was waved off.
Pierre Maguire suggested (and yes, I realize that this kills any credability to the notion right there for some of you ) that it could work like this:
If the team making the challenge has not yet used their timeout, they would lose it if the initial call was upheld.
If they had already used their timeout, they would get a Delay Of Game penalty if the initial call was upheld.
So; what do you think? Is this accepable, or would you suggest something else - or do we even need a Coach's Challenge in the first place?
Pierre Maguire suggested (and yes, I realize that this kills any credability to the notion right there for some of you ) that it could work like this:
If the team making the challenge has not yet used their timeout, they would lose it if the initial call was upheld.
If they had already used their timeout, they would get a Delay Of Game penalty if the initial call was upheld.
So; what do you think? Is this accepable, or would you suggest something else - or do we even need a Coach's Challenge in the first place?