Top 10 QBs in the NFL, today

[msgkings322]

So not Brady from 5 years ago. Today.

Obviously like all lists like this there's no scientific way to prove 1 is better than 2 or 3 better than 4. The best QBs are all really good, and there's no way to prove who's better. But here goes:

Mahomes
Jackson
Rodgers
Brees
Wilson
Brady
Cousins
Garoppolo
Watson
Prescott

As I said, the actual order isn't set in stone, you can make a case to move guys around.

Just missed: Goff, Ryan (and you can make a case they are top 10)

Let's see just how gay @HaroldSeattle is, if he ducks this.

 

[msgkings322]

This QBR list is pretty good. Jimmy G not so hot on here though. But would you take Wentz over him? Fitzpatrick, Carr, Tannehill? Not me.

It does show JG with a higher QBR than Brady and Rodgers so....

2019 NFL Season Leaders Total QBR | ESPN

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Those QBs you have below Jimmy are better. Jimmy is a fraud. He has a very good coach, great run game, a OK to good defense, but Jimmy isn't any thing special especially for how long he's been in the league. He's middle of the road basically. None of his numbers jump out at all. He's simply OK, certainly not special as you seem to feel. If you like we can look at his career numbers and take that in consideration. Probably should if you feel he's a proven winner .

 

[msgkings322]

Those QBs you have below Jimmy are better. Jimmy is a fraud. He has a very good coach, great run game, a OK to good defense, but Jimmy isn't any thing special especially for how long he's been in the league. He's middle of the road basically. None of his numbers jump out at all. He's simply OK, certainly not special as you seem to feel. If you like we can look at his career numbers and take that in consideration. Probably should if you feel he's a proven winner .

Yes let's. I'll start: only started 25 games so he hasn't 'been in the league' that long as a starting QB. Oh but he did go 20-5 in those games.

Look, I'm not saying the kid is MVP. But most QBs are trash, a few are just guys. This dude is a winner, he has carried the team to a couple victories, he has been clutch. He's lower end of the top 10. There's not 10 others I would want TODAY (i.e. no Brady, Rivers, others way past their primes).

Also, still waiting to see your top 10 and stop bitching about mine.

 

[Dude]

Good to see Brady in there, had a rough stretch, keep up the good work going forward.

 

[msgkings322]

Good to see Brady in there, had a rough stretch, keep it going forward.

Gimme your list! I'm all alone out here...

 

[HaroldSeattle]

His career stats starting in 2014 which was long ago, so yes he has been in the league a long time learning from one of the best with Tom Brady and Bill B. as his coach.

 

[msgkings322]

His career stats starting in 2014 which was long ago, so yes he has been in the league a long time learning from one of the best with Tom Brady and Bill B. as his coach.

View attachment 227342

You ever gonna shut up and give us your list?

 

[Battlelyon]

1-9 Wentz
10 Lamar Jackson

 

[HaroldSeattle]

You ever gonna shut up and give us your list?

Just take your list and put Jimmy below everyone you listed , that should suffice.

 

[msgkings322]

Just take your list and put Jimmy below everyone you listed , that should suffice.

So you got nothing. I guess it's just this for you:

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Yes let's. I'll start: only started 25 games so he hasn't 'been in the league' that long as a starting QB. Oh but he did go 20-5 in those games.

Look, I'm not saying the kid is MVP. But most QBs are trash, a few are just guys. This dude is a winner, he has carried the team to a couple victories, he has been clutch. He's lower end of the top 10. There's not 10 others I would want TODAY (i.e. no Brady, Rivers, others way past their primes).

Also, still waiting to see your top 10 and stop bitching about mine.

This is pretty much his first year for putting up stats that matter. He's already been in the league since 2014. None of his stats shout special.

 

[Dude]

Will the Browns beat the Ravens again is a question. Sounds very unlikely.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

So you got nothing. I guess it's just this for you:

Going to bed, otherwise I'm going to start giving you what your dishing out and I'd rather not get in the ditch with you. Your the one with nothing. Give me one stat that says Jimmy is special, just one. I bet when I get up and look at this thread you won't be able to produce a single stat that indicates Jimmy is special.

 

[msgkings322]

Going to bed, otherwise I'm going to start giving you what your dishing out and I'd rather not get in the ditch with you. Your the one with nothing. Give me one stat that says Jimmy is special, just one. I bet when I get up and look at this thread you won't be able to produce a single stat that indicates Jimmy is special.

Obviously your top 10 list won't have Jimmy, fine, nothing I say will convince you. So, who do you like? This thread is a top 10 QB thread, I'm genuinely curious where you and others see these guys today.

 

[Robotech]

Okay, the definitive list of the best signal callers in today's game:

Jackson
Mahomes
Rodgers
Wilson
Brees
Brady
Cousins
Watson
Tannehill
Garoppolo
Prescott
Stafford
Carr
Ryan
Brissett
Goff
Wentz
Mayfield
Josh Allen
Trubisky
Rivers
Minshew
Murray
Winston
Fitzpatrick
Dalton
Eli Manning
Lock
Darnold
Haskins
Kyle Allen
Hodges

 

[wazzu31]

Any QB list with Minshew II not in the top 5 is a fail. I mean Foles turned the pitiful Eagles into Super Bowl champs but can barely get a touchdown in Jacksonville yet the Stache got them in semi playoff contention. Stache is number 3 behind LayJay and Patty Ice.

 

[broncosmitty]

Wilson
Brees
Rodgers
Brady
Jackson
dudes I don't see becoming Champions at starting QB this year, or are disqualified.
Eli

 

[msgkings322]

Why is it so hard for you goombahs to just list 10 QBs? Sheesh.

 

[Robotech]

Why is it so hard for you goombahs to just list 10 QBs? Sheesh.

Do I get extra credit?