Sportshoopla top 25 week 11 discussion thread

[BoiseStateFan27]

You have way, way overreacted dropping Georgia from 1 to 10, and I thought you was a person that didn't overreact. 6 is the correct position for Georgia based on how great they have played the whole season and the body of work they have.

Anyway here is my poll as now. Do I need to makes any changes? The last several spots of the top 25 were very difficult to come up with it

1.(2) Alabama 10-0
2.(4) Miami 9-0
3.(6) Oklahoma 9-1
4.(5) Clemson 9-1
5.(7)Wisconsin 10-0
6.(1) Georgia 9-1
7.(13) Auburn 8-2
8.(10) UCF 9-0
9.(3) Notre Dame 8-2
10.(14) Ohio St. 8-2
11.(12) USC 9-2
12.(15) Penn St. 8-2
13. (9) TCU 8-2
14.(16) Oklahoma St. 8-2
15.(8) Washington 8-2
16.(18) Washington St. 9-2
17.(19) Memphis 8-1
18.(20) Michigan 8-2
19.(21) Mississippi State 7-3
20.(23) South Florida 8-1
21.(NR) Stanford 7-3
22.(NR) LSU 7-3
23((NR) Arizona 7-3
24(NR) W. Virginia 7-3
25(11) Mich St. 7-3

Their body of work was basically a quality win over Notre Dame and that's it. Miami destroyed Notre Dame, taking the shine off that win to pair with the loss

I can see dropping Georgia down

reading your poll I realized I forgot to rank Arizona

 

[4down20]

Yep...kind of the opposite of what is "normal" for Bama.

Well, a position normally filled by names like Rolando McClain, Donta Hightower. CJ Mosley and Rueben Foster is being played by a white boy named Keith Holcombe.

And I feel sorry for the guy really. He was a 4 star and he's not really terrible, but he has some huge shoes and expectations to fill and he had a really bad game is a nice way to say it.

Not going to win many football games when everyone can just run it up the middle on you.

 

[dennis580]

There is no reason why Georgia should be ranked above Auburn here. Surely you messed up? I mean, you at minimum switch them.

Auburn has 2 losses and is not yet comparable to Georgia yet. The decision for Georgia at #6 was very easy. They have been dominant most of the year and still have the high quality road win over N. Dame and a quality blowout over Miss St. They were the clear #1 coming into the week. Yea the game at Auburn certainly was terrible, but we shouldn't go crazy and overreact.

 

[dennis580]

Their body of work was basically a quality win over Notre Dame and that's it. Miami destroyed Notre Dame, taking the shine off that win to pair with the loss

I can see dropping Georgia down

reading your poll I realized I forgot to rank Arizona

Don't forget the blowout of Miss St. another quality win. Miss St. actually moved up in my poll from 21 to 19 after there perfomance against Bama. Very rare for a team to move up after a loss, but Miss St deserved to move up after that game against Bama

 

[4down20]

Auburn has 2 losses and is not yet comparable to Georgia yet. The decision for Georgia at #6 was very easy. They have been dominant most of the year and still have the high quality road win over N. Dame and a quality blowout over Miss St. They were the clear #1 coming into the week. Yea the game at Auburn certainly was terrible, but we shouldn't go crazy and overreact.

He has Georgia 1 rank ahead of Auburn. If they are that close, I don't think it's crazy or an over reaction to switch them.

 

[BoiseStateFan27]

Don't forget the blowout of Miss St. another quality win. Miss St. actually moved up in my poll from 21 to 19 after there perfomance against Bama. Very rare for a team to move up after a loss, but Miss St deserved to move up after that game against Bama

I don't consider them impressive, been blown out by any competition worth a crap until this weekend

Bama was beat up and not focused last night, then when Alabama got focused Mississippi State folded like a cheap lawn chair

 

[kburjr]

@Volbound1700 Was not ranking Wisconsin at all an oversight?

 

[Vadered]

@Volbound1700 Was not ranking Wisconsin at all an oversight?

Yeah, he's got Washington at 5 and 15. Thinking Wisconsin is supposed to be 5.

 

[The Crimson King]

Lol @ auburn at 13

 

[LambeauLegs]

1. Alabama
2. Miami
3. Oklahoma
4. Clemson
5. Washington
6. Auburn
7. Georgia
8. Ohio State
9. Notre Dame
10. TCU
11. Oklahoma State
12. USC
13. Penn State
14. UCF
15. Washington
16. LSU
17. Michigan
18. Washington State
19. Memphis
20. Mississippi State
21. Stanford
22. Michigan State
23. South Carolina
24. NC State
25. Northwestern

Good thing you are not on the playoff committee with Wisconsin not in your top 25

 

[Volbound1700]

Good thing you are not on the playoff committee with Wisconsin not in your top 25

1. Alabama
2. Miami
3. Oklahoma
4. Clemson
5. Wisconsin
6. Auburn
7. Georgia
8. Ohio State
9. Notre Dame
10. TCU
11. Oklahoma State
12. USC
13. Penn State
14. UCF
15. Washington
16. LSU
17. Michigan
18. Washington State
19. Memphis
20. Mississippi State
21. Stanford
22. Michigan State
23. South Carolina
24. NC State
25. Northwestern

Not sure why I put Washington and not Wisconsin at #5. Fixed it.

 

[Edisto_Tiger]

THE VOTING THREAD IS FOR VOTING!!!

Discussion goes in the DISCUSSION thread!

 

[Chewbaccer]

THE VOTING THREAD IS FOR VOTING!!!

Discussion goes in the DISCUSSION thread!

I've even been making the discussion thread first so there's a link to the discussion thread in the OP of the voting thread and some people still fuck it up.