So say we had a four agme playoff this season who is in

[Scorpion14]

My choice would be Michigan State, Auburn, Stanford, and Florida State. All won their championship so this should be it. Anybody disagree with this.

 

[Steelboy84]

Hate the idea of a playoff. I also hate all of these conference title games. Before the Big10 had a title game, OSU would have been in the title game after beating michigan.

 

[OregonDucks]

drop a 2 loss Stanford team and put in Alabama.

 

[Steelboy84]

FSU proved they were the best in the ACC in the reg season, so what was the point of tonight's game? Same with OSU.

 

[OregonDucks]

FSU proved they were the best in the ACC in the reg season, so what was the point of tonight's game? Same with OSU.

what? MSU was undefeated in the B1G as well.

 

[Steelboy84]

what? MSU was undefeated in the B1G as well.

This is where I agree with OSU fans. They were undefeated. MSU was not.

 

[sakau2007]

4 team playoff would be brutal for auburn. path to a title would be 4 straight games over the top 5 to close the season.

 

[theboardref]

4 team playoff would be brutal for auburn. path to a title would be 4 straight games over the top 5 to clise the swason.

Yea, would be the first time anyone tried to clise a swason.

 

[Bamabino]

Clise a swason? Must be what a raghead does with a goat.

 

[Scorpion14]

I know some will say Alabama should be in but they didn't win their conference. The bad thing about this is none of these conferences play each other so know one knows. We have a system today where the polls start out every year its full of SEC teams and throughout the year they just flip flop.

The truth is if a team should be ticked of it should be Baylor and not Alabama.

 

[theboardref]

I know some will say Alabama should be in but they didn't win their conference. The bad thing about this is none of these conferences play each other so know one knows. We have a system today where the polls start out every year its full of SEC teams and throughout the year they just flip flop.

The truth is if a team should be ticked of it should be Baylor and not Alabama.

Baylor lost a lot of credibility after getting manhandled by Oklahoma State. They have no reason to be mad. Baylor has no conference title game and got dominated in their biggest game of the year.

 

[rmilia1]

If there was one this year itd be auburn, bama, fsu as locks. Last spot would be either msu or stanford. Probably msy

 

[LawDawg]

We had another thread on this the other day.

FSU
Auburn
Bama
MSU/Baylor - I'd go with Baylor

 

[SeattleCoug]

1.FSU vs 4. Michigan State
2. Auburn vs. 3. Alabama

 

[Innermind]

1.FSU vs 4. Michigan State
2. Auburn vs. 3. Alabama

I concur.

Would Stanford and Baylor be pissed.....sure they would. I believe that almost every season under the new 4-team play-off system there are going to be angry fan bases of the teams chosen/seeded #5 and #6.

 

[dirtboy068]

1.FSU vs 4. Michigan State
2. Auburn vs. 3. Alabama

THIS

 

[Tubbs1518]

Bama couldn't win their conference, they shouldn't be in. Plain and simple.

 

[phantomfoul88]

I would love an 8 team playoff

 

[bamabear82]

Bama couldn't win their conference, they shouldn't be in. Plain and simple.

I just want the best teams in. You're not gonna get that if you only take conference champs and I'd take Bama over pretty much any other conference champ not named FSU.

 

[BoomerNTX]

Pitting Bama and Aub is 2012 NCG all over again. Replace LSU with Aub. If you beat a team in the regular season, should you have to beat them again in a NCG? Should a team thats 2nd(or 3rd) best in its own conference get a chance to be in the big dance? Sure Bama is a good team. No disputes there. But they lost to Auburn and didn't even play in their own CCG. Most, outside of team SEC, realize that the BCS is like going to Vegas. The rest of Div I is playing against a stacked deck, when the SEC led voting block puts half or more of their teams in the top 25 each season. Its easier to hold on to the top 25 then to bust your way in. If we want to see who is the best, we need to have an environment that allows the best, no matter where they come from, to compete. There are some very good teams out there. Every other sport figures out who is the best in their division, conference and then the country. The BCS has failed in this regard. It is a system that is more about where you're from than what you've done. Sooo...

1) FSU
2) Aub
3) MSU
4) BU

If the system expands to 8 or 12 team playoff, then we can consider wildcard options(Bama, OU, UO, tOSU, etc). In the mean time, you have 4 teams from 4 power conferences. Sure, the PAC is left out in this scenario, but their Conf champ is a 2 loss team and the others are 0/1 loss teams.

Just my two pesos.