NFL Phase Draft Play-In Game : Milk vs Shane

[TheRobotDevil]

While I somewhat agree, who stops Moss, Johnson, Hutson plus a hand off to Payton...? I think Shane gets one more stop or maybe he gets the ball last with little time left... it's pretty close but I think his offense has one extra score vs the defense...

I don't know both the offenses are pretty even.But the defenses are also capable of making this game difficult.Both evenly matched great teams imo.Who are the kickers?

 

[Mebert]

I really don't care for the 2 HB idea. I think a second TE or a FB would be much better. Outside of that I like Milks team more. I think he has enough to over come that mistake

Milk

 

[Shanemansj13]

I disagree... Sharpe was the better overall TE but Graham is one of the best receiving TEs ever... Better than Sharpe... Plus, there is a 5 inch difference which is significant in the red zone... And Hayes is better than Hutson, only because he does more for my team than hutson does yours... Hayes is the best speed receiver and will spread the field to just make Owens and Rice better... Hutson, doesn't really make anyone better, he is just great on his own...

Sharpe is still better imo. Graham is more athletic and some could argue he was part of that Saints system. I still have Graham top 5.

Hutson is a top 3 WR on a lot of lists, never saw him play so I cant see. I really dont need a speed guy bc I have two tall, athletic WR's that ran 4.4's. Hutson could be a great slot guy like Welker but that is the problem, we don't know. We do know he was one of the greatest ar his position of all-time

 

[wlk3]

id say my secondary is better than his while his defensive line is better than mine... But we both have impossible to defend offenses... I do think my offensive weapons are better though...

I'd agree with that defensive assessment... but I think your secondary is slightly better while I think his dline is much better or maybe I should say his edge rushers... I have to lean Marino in a shootout if you give him Moss and Johnson... I don't want to continue as I don't want to influence any votes against you... I will say your team is very good and it's a close one, I just think Shane has a one score edge...

 

[Shanemansj13]

Sorry Moss ran a 4.25. Sorry guys lol

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I'd agree with that defensive assessment... but I think your secondary is slightly better while I think his dline is much better or maybe I should say his edge rushers... I have to lean Marino in a shootout if you give him Moss and Johnson... I don't want to continue as I don't want to influence any votes against you... I will say your team is very good and it's a close one, I just think Shane has a one score edge...

I actually don't understand your view at all... Shane's line backers are what makes his line great... but his defensive ends and tackles are not as good as mine...

 

[Shanemansj13]

I also saw somewhere Huston ran a 9.7 100 yard dash...which probably says he runs a 4.5 or so, bc of old school timing methods lo

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Sorry Moss ran a 4.25. Sorry guys lol

I also saw somewhere Huston ran a 9.7 100 yard dash...which probably says he runs a 4.5 or so, bc of old school timing methods lo

Al Davis?

 

[Nosferatu]

I think these teams are so close that its literally a coin flip, Marino to Moss is about as good as it could get. I actually like the two back set because he picked two completely different style backs, Bobby Bell is one of the most underrated players of all time. I think I lean Milk here, I think....

 

[Nosferatu]

So Devil have you voted yet? Remember everyone its first to 5...

 

[TheRobotDevil]

So Devil have you voted yet? Remember everyone its first to 5...

I may have looked at the line ups. More times than a female student at Baylor. I wasn't sure about milks backfield. But I do actually like it. I also like Payton too tho. I think the wr's are pretty even in these systems. As far as QB I would feel bad for any QB in this draft.I think Shane has the edge at TE Looking at the defenses the front 7,s are pretty even. Shane's got a great front 3 for a 3-4. And great LBs. But I also think milk has a great front 4. And like the combo of Bell and urlacher.Slight edge to milk in the secondary. I really wish I could vote for both and hate seeing anyone lose. I've got milk on a literal coin flip

 

[wlk3]

I actually don't understand your view at all... Shane's line backers are what makes his line great... but his defensive ends and tackles are not as good as mine...

You highlighted "or should I say edge rushers" then said you didn't understand... his front 3 are solid but his edge rushers are excellent... that's where your problem is... while they are labeled LBs they are edge rushers that play on the line...

 

[UK Cowboy]

Shane

 

[femurov]

I disagree... Sharpe was the better overall TE but Graham is one of the best receiving TEs ever... Better than Sharpe... Plus, there is a 5 inch difference which is significant in the red zone... And Hayes is better than Hutson, only because he does more for my team than hutson does yours... Hayes is the best speed receiver and will spread the field to just make Owens and Rice better... Hutson, doesn't really make anyone better, he is just great on his own...

I vote for Shane just because Milk says that Bullet Bob is better than Don Hutson.

 

[Nosferatu]

500 decides it...

 

[Pack 500]

I almost had to vote for Shane because Milk doesn't have Harold Carmichael but Milk's secondary gives him the win

 

[Shanemansj13]

Just remember you voted for a guy that thinks Bob Hayes is better than Don Hutson lol

 

[Nosferatu]

Congrats Milk, I expect a bunch of these games to be this close...

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I almost had to vote for Shane because Milk doesn't have Harold Carmichael but Milk's secondary gives him the win

I do love Harold Carmichael teamed up with with either Bob Hayes or cliff branch. But nobody wanted to trade for jerry rice

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Just remember you voted for a guy that thinks Bob Hayes is better than Don Hutson lol

To be fair, I under-rate everyone named Don